Aaron Smith Levin on the Collapse of SCN in California



Thanks, that was an excellent update on the legendary "IDEAL ORGS" in California, and very specifically the Orange County Ideal Org.

I wonder about the few remaining Scientologists in Orange County when they are finally being pushed to attend a "very special super upstat VIP briefing about how the OC Ideal Org is now in the position to become the world's first Clear county!". It is a certainty that when they attend the briefing, the cult won't mention that:

- - When they say the org is "ideal" it actually means "desperately close to going out of business entirely".​
​
- - When they say they are going to Clear that county, they are talking about 3.2 million people. And​
since Scientology first began clearing people in Orange county in the 1950s, they have, to date, produced zero clears.​

These things do not bother Scientologists. Here are appx. 5000 super-uptone Scientologists wildly cheering on the day that the Orange County Ideal Org opened!

1678159771803.jpeg
​
They are not bothered by Scientology's lies because that's why they joined the cult and exactly what they are paying lavish sums for.

..
 
Last edited:
That was a great, great video!

We've been long overdue to have a public face on our side who could deliver
the same set of critical talking points again and again. The same talking points
that need to be pounded on over and over!

A-Aron sounds like a guy who went to school at Vince McMahon's School for Delivering
a Wrestling Promo
. Just a phenomenal ability to deliver lines or a story that just not
everyone can muster. He's a natural.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
I'll differ with A-Aron on one small point: my guesstimate for the total membership
for years has been 15-20,000. I had "insider" sources a decade ago myself. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

What I wrote in 2014 on ESMB:​
Five years ago when the Truth Rundown videos and Marty's blog went public, I told a friend the information that was made public would eventually penetrate throughout the whole org via auditor worksheets of PreOTs who had read or seen the stories. First the CS reads the worksheet, then the Ethics Officer handling the PreOT hears all about it, and then the information passes on to nosy execs who are wondering what's happening with the PreOT on the lines.​
​
My feeling was that you just can't stop ALL this information from penetrating and poisoning the entire tech and exec strata of any advanced org in time. You just can't stop the "entheta" and it will slowly plant seeds of doubt over time.​
​
I joked further when the Lawrence Wright book Going Clear came out that people who had read his book and had questions or concerns would have to be put on a special routing form to keep the "Sarge reveals" from being too broadly known inside.​
​
I would think in time any CS would eventually get "poisoned" by the outside information leaking in through misbehaving PreOTs on the lines.​
​
I concluded once the whistle is blown by major SO people who have escaped . . . it's just a matter of time before everyone inside gets pretty tainted by all the extraordinary reveals.​
​
I hold by my 2014 post. This is how it happens. The news gets into the castle that has massively thick
impenetrable walls via the water carrier. Always.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
"But it [truth] is always there, whether we can see it or not, whether​
we choose to or not. The truth doesn't care about our needs or wants.​
It doesn't care about our governments, our ideologies, our religions.​
It will lie in wait, for all time."​
HBO Series Chernobyl​
 
Last edited:
"You have this enormous citadel sitting on the high crown of an untouchable mount.​
And it is garrisoned and provisioned and watered to withstand the siege of centuries.​
And its garrison is well-trained and well armed."​
​
"Not a single shaft or a bolt or a lightning flash could go through that citadel. But by​
the water carrier or some other means an idea can go through the wall of any ​
citadel. When you ask, ”What is the strength of this garrison?” you always have to ask,​
”What is the loyalty of this garrison?” ​
PDC 10​

:omg: :omg: :omg:
:coolwink:
 
I'll differ with A-Aron on one small point: my guesstimate for the total membership
for years has been 15-20,000.

i missed the number he gave; what was it?

i think i've seen insider information suggesting the IAS has 30k members in good standing -- but that of course would include a lot of people who bought (or were pushed into buying) life memberships long ago, who are no longer involved but who didn't get declared when they slipped away. if that's what he's using, it's a safe number that i don't think the CoS could ever prove wrong; and in the big picture, whether there are 15k or 30k members in a world with a population over 8 billion, they are still a tiny cult lying through their teeth when they claim to have millions or even any significant number of members anywhere (typically they punch above their weight in CW civic affairs, but don't even have enough people to affect elections).

it seems to me that 15k is about the number of people even active enough, that they'll show up for major events one or more times a year. my reality check is that works out to over 100 members per local org -- and when do we ever see event photos showing even that many people? of course there are now a couple thousand in CW who only are involved with Flag, and probably some in LA who really only do anything with AOLA (a while back there was even a push, to try to get or force people like that to join local org OT committees), plus of course 3-4k in the sea org, but i think those just backfill for the reality that most local orgs no longer even have 100 people showing up, or at most push the 15k number up to 20k.
 
i missed the number he gave; what was it?

i think i've seen insider information suggesting the IAS has 30k members in good standing -- but that of course would include a lot of people who bought (or were pushed into buying) life memberships long ago, who are no longer involved but who didn't get declared when they slipped away. if that's what he's using, it's a safe number that i don't think the CoS could ever prove wrong; and in the big picture, whether there are 15k or 30k members in a world with a population over 8 billion, they are still a tiny cult lying through their teeth when they claim to have millions or even any significant number of members anywhere (typically they punch above their weight in CW civic affairs, but don't even have enough people to affect elections).

it seems to me that 15k is about the number of people even active enough, that they'll show up for major events one or more times a year. my reality check is that works out to over 100 members per local org -- and when do we ever see event photos showing even that many people? of course there are now a couple thousand in CW who only are involved with Flag, and probably some in LA who really only do anything with AOLA (a while back there was even a push, to try to get or force people like that to join local org OT committees), plus of course 3-4k in the sea org, but i think those just backfill for the reality that most local orgs no longer even have 100 people showing up, or at most push the 15k number up to 20k.


When they promote that they have millions of members I agree it makes little difference whether the real number is 15K or 30K.

There are IMO multiple reasons why they lie about this. They want their own members to believe that Scientology is not a tiny cult, but rather has a significant presence worldwide. And just as important if not more so, when OSA interacts with governments they want the government representatives to believe that OSA is representing an organization of millions as it will impact how governments deal with the CoS.
 
When they promote that they have millions of members I agree it makes little difference whether the real number is 15K or 30K.

There are IMO multiple reasons why they lie about this. They want their own members to believe that Scientology is not a tiny cult, but rather has a significant presence worldwide. And just as important if not more so, when OSA interacts with governments they want the government representatives to believe that OSA is representing an organization of millions as it will impact how governments deal with the CoS.
And the followers will keep (mostly) be-lie-ving that there are a shit ton of scn'ists to stroke their myside bias. Actually, maybe the bias comes from being told there are millions in opposition to what they see everyday at the org. Maybe one good thing that comes from this is the occasional cognition that the "millions" they are told about in promo, events, etc. aren't anywhere to be found. Trust me on this cog.

(As a note, the very first thing that I searched when I knew I wasn't going back was just that, the "how many" question.)
 
They definitely want to keep current members misinformed. I know current Scientologists who are still confident there are millions of Scientologists worldwide. A small bit of thinking and a little bit of math would easily disprove it, but they are happy to just parrot what they get told in events. Scientology/DM's insistence on always painting a false picture of unprecedented expansion, while really orgs are struggling to stay open at all, will eventually catch up to them.

In addition to the overall numbers you have to look at the demographics. I think their aging population is going to be something they can't overcome. Sure, they do have some younger members (2nd/3rd gen) but most of the hardcore, going to be on staff or in the SO till they die, are getting up there in age.
 
When I was a staff member at Boston Org for 7 years during the 80s I couldn't understand how an organization that had the greatest tech in this sector of the universe was struggling to keep toilet paper in the bathrooms or pay anything to staff ( I was making about 30 cents/hour on the average). :scratch:

But I just figured that that was the situation at Boston Org and the rest of Scientology was OK. :)
 
i think i've seen insider information suggesting the IAS has 30k members in good standing -- but that of course would include a lot of people who bought (or were pushed into buying) life memberships long ago, who are no longer involved but who didn't get declared when they slipped away.
My wife and I are probably two of them. As far as I know we haven't been "officially" declared, just disaffected and inactive.

The real number would be calculated as "how many have shown up into the org building in the last year?"
 
Ed Dearborn, that's the name I was trying to remember. Does anyone know if something happened to him? Did he get declared or otherwise taken off post? That would've been a sure way to crash OC. I thought I heard of something like that happening, but I could be getting mixed up.

If anything this goes to highlight how hard California has been hit in recent years. I've heard of tons of scientologists leaving the state, with Clearwater the most popular destination.
 
Ed Dearborn, that's the name I was trying to remember. Does anyone know if something happened to him? Did he get declared or otherwise taken off post? That would've been a sure way to crash OC. I thought I heard of something like that happening, but I could be getting mixed up.

If anything this goes to highlight how hard California has been hit in recent years. I've heard of tons of scientologists leaving the state, with Clearwater the most popular destination.
A bunch of scn'ists have left Atlanta as well over the past few years. Really, it's a large percentage if you consider now how few are left
 
My wife and I are probably two of them. As far as I know we haven't been "officially" declared, just disaffected and inactive.

The real number would be calculated as "how many have shown up into the org building in the last year?"
If you wanted to stat push memberships anyone who signs up for any scientology service is given a free membership, or used to, and then they should renew after a certain amount of time. This rarely happens as they tended to leave before finishing their basic course. The membership could be counted as a new member, but conveniently forgetting to take their membership off when they failed to renew by buying a yearly or lifetime membership. This is an easy way to completely false reports memberships. I think investigation would show that no on ever comes off the membership stats, even if they are excommunicated or dead, and that it is completely false.
 
In a recent video, he was way too generous with his guesstimates, IMO. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Fwiw, I agree that it is heavy. I think that number may have been closer to the actual truth in 2015 - 2017. I think it was contracting as it has been doing for years before the covid craziness. Covid allowed some to get some space and look. I think it's more like 25k or less.
 
The only time I ever knew a Sea Org member tell the truth about the membership number was sometime in the 1990s when a senior IAS official was trying to get more money out of me. I said something on the lines of: "Why is it always me who has to give money to save the planet? There are millions of scientologists so why is it always up to me?". She said: "I'm going to tell you something in confidence, ok? The total number of IAS members worldwide is 68,000".

I had a moment to consider this and I said to her that I knew the IAS membership included public, raw public, staff and Sea Org so she was telling me there were only 68,000 scientologists on the planet? She replied: "Yes. It's a good job the SPs don't know isn't it?"
 
The total number of IAS members worldwide is 68,000

thanks for that account. and i think that would have been about the high water mark at a point when the co$ was still doing fairly well, and probably had a lot of people on the books who kept up memberships or had bought lifetime ones, who'd been involved during peak years but rarely actually showed up anymore -- at a major org event i got an insider invite to about a decade ago, there seemed to be a lot of people going back to that very era, some coming from outlying areas where there had been missions during scn's heyday, and i was told about half those in attendance only showed up around twice a year.

the figure i remember seeing, though i can't say where, is that a recent version of that number is 30k or maybe 35k.

eta: i was just reminded, we see accounts of people buying lifetime memberships for their children as young as infants, so there are people on the IAS rolls who aren't adults doing services, including those who were given memberships at a young age but as adults drifted away.
 
Last edited:
The only time I ever knew a Sea Org member tell the truth about the membership number was sometime in the 1990s when a senior IAS official was trying to get more money out of me. I said something on the lines of: "Why is it always me who has to give money to save the planet? There are millions of scientologists so why is it always up to me?". She said: "I'm going to tell you something in confidence, ok? The total number of IAS members worldwide is 68,000". I had a moment to consider this and I said to her that I knew the IAS membership included public, raw public, staff and Sea Org so she was telling me there were only 68,000 scientologists on the planet? She replied: "Yes. It's a good job the SPs don't know isn't it?"


Why in the 1990s the COS was promoting that they had both "over 10M members" and also "68,000" members?

EXPLANATION: Because Scientology is the game where everyone wins! In fact it's the "only game in the universe where everyone wins!" Therefore, in adherence to the "Hubbard Law of Commotion":

- - If there are over 10M Scientologists that is a hugely epic win!​
​
- - If there are really only 68,000 Scientologists that is also a hugely epic win, because the cult's​
enemies were successfully prevented from discovering this strategically super-secret data!​

This Hubbardian gimmick of telling two diametrically opposite versions of the same story is manifest in anything and everything that Scientologists call an "R" factor. R for reality? No. R for ridiculous. Just for fun let's cite another one of those preposterous"always winning" assertions:

- - If Scientology's lines are completely free of entheta, lawsuits, criminal prosecutions, protests and widescale media uproar, it means that the tech is working beautifully!​
​
- - If Scientology's lines are completely overwhelmed with entheta, lawsuits, criminal prosecutions, protests and widescale media uproar, that also means that the tech is working beautifully! ​

Because (Hubbard assures): "...people only attack us when we are flourishing and prospering and our tech is working!"

PRO TIP FOR SCIENTOLOGY: You should seriously consider changing your motto from "We Come Back" to "WINNUS PERPETUALIS!" Always winning!*

..

*Hey, Ron's not really dead, it's just that he is so OT he had to kill his body which is such an amazing epic win!

..
 
Why in the 1990s the COS was promoting that they had both "over 10M members" and also "68,000" members?

i think you may be missing some transcription or punctuation/capitalization error, like the difference beween '20 million members' and '68,000 IAS Members'

i could see it being sort of like in a totalitarian country, where say everyone is a communist, but there are only a limited number of Communist Party Members....
 
eta: i was just reminded, we see accounts of people buying lifetime memberships for their children as young as infants, so there are people on the IAS rolls who aren't adults doing services, including those who were given memberships at a young age but as adults drifted away.
I bought an IAS yearly membership for our first baby back in the 90's.

Then money was tight, didn't renew the kid's membership, and got a VERY nasty letter from IAS addressed to the kid over the non-renewal.
 
Back
Top