The Insider speaks: Scientology’s recent crises, now in a podcast with Chris Shelton

Karen#1

Well-known member
Excerpt:

Late last year, we got some eye-opening reports on how hard the pandemic has been on Scientology from someone inside the organization. We dubbed them The Insider, and they told us about chaos caused by Covid, new details on the ‘Chase Wave’ financial debacle, a detailed description of the Ideal Org scam, and even told us about the new ‘Golden Age of Admin’ that was on the way.

We’ve really enjoyed talking to this new source, and now they’ve decided to provide even more detail by talking to Chris Shelton. Here’s Chris’s description of today’s video…~~~READ MORE

 
I was really looking forward to part 2 of the Katherine Olson interview (I want to hear the behind the scenes on kc/Columbus) but this isn't bad. Not really any new information, we've talked about most of the stuff he brings up, but it does confirm a lot of our speculation.
 
I was really looking forward to part 2 of the Katherine Olson interview (I want to hear the behind the scenes on kc/Columbus) but this isn't bad. Not really any new information, we've talked about most of the stuff he brings up, but it does confirm a lot of our speculation.

i found it interesting that they pegged local org staff at 12 to 15, which is what i've figured it must be these days from what i can tell, though it seems to be hard to find anyone who's very sure of the numbers. there may be a couple of larger orgs as we've discussed in other threads, but some of the tiny struggling ones only have around half that from what i've picked up.
 
i found it interesting that they pegged local org staff at 12 to 15, which is what i've figured it must be these days from what i can tell, though it seems to be hard to find anyone who's very sure of the numbers. there may be a couple of larger orgs as we've discussed in other threads, but some of the tiny struggling ones only have around half that from what i've picked up.

It's hard to get a read on the numbers because Scientology is never going to release them (are they even tracking them?) and on top of that there isn't much logic for which orgs are bigger and which are smaller. It's pretty random, e.g. Cincinnati being one of the biggest EUS orgs, if not the biggest, for a long time.

15ish staff is probably not too far off, though I still think it's around 15 per shift, i.e. 15 on Day and 15 on Foundation. Not totally clear if he was talking about the org as a whole or per shift. The bigger orgs probably skew the average, the average could be 30-40 per org (counting both shifts), but most orgs could be in the 20 or less range.

I think it's easier to accurately guess the number of SO members, not that many SO bases so easier to get a count. I think anywhere from 3000-6000 SO members sounds accurate, though I'd put it towards the lower end of that range. I expect there are similar numbers of staff.
 
It's hard to get a read on the numbers because Scientology is never going to release them (are they even tracking them?) and on top of that there isn't much logic for which orgs are bigger and which are smaller.

i would expect that exes and UTRs could readily provide information about just how many staff there were or are at their local org, including what the mix of full time and part time was. yet it seems very hard to find someone providing a clear count.

if it's not 12-15 total at average local orgs, then how could it be that none of the dozens of event photos that have come out in recent years, including for New Years' and LRH Birthday events (below) that should be virtual 'all hands' calls, ever show more than 3 to 4 dozen people? could there really be orgs that had 25 to 30 full time staff serving just around 50 active members, and perhaps even as few as half that who were truly active? (i was once told that such events at one local org, were about half long time members who were hardly ever seen except at major social events, including those from outlying missions)

SCN Philadaelphia-New-Years-Event converted.jpg

SCN Philadelpia 2019 Rons-Bday converted.jpg
 
Last edited:
i would expect that exes and UTRs could readily provide information about just how many staff there were or are at their local org, including what the mix of full time and part time was. yet it seems very hard to find someone providing a clear count.

if it's not 12-15 total at average local orgs, then how could it be that none of the dozens of event photos that have come out in recent years, including for New Years' and LRH Birthday events (below) that should be virtual 'all hands' calls, ever show more than 3 to 4 dozen people? could there really be orgs that had 25 to 30 full time staff serving just around 50 active members, and perhaps even as few as half that who were truly active? (i was once told that such events at one local org, were about half long time members who were hardly ever seen except at major social events, including those from outlying missions)

View attachment 18273

View attachment 18272

My point is just that it's hard to get counts because there's a ton of variation, and it's pretty random. We could get some accurate counts from recent exes, but that only gives us info from that one org from that one time period, not anything that can be applied to other orgs.

There probably are plenty of orgs that have 10-15 staff total, but there are also some bigger orgs that are going to throw off the overall average. Didn't we have a recent defector from Tampa that said they had something like 200 staff? I forget if that was per shift or total. Either way, these bigger orgs are going to skew the average. If you have 50 orgs but the biggest 5 have 1000 staff between them, well we already have an average of 20 without even counting anything from the other 45 orgs.

It's mostly guesswork, unless we have firsthand accounts from people who recently left.

The only thing I'm sure of, in the last 5 years class v staff numbers have plummeted, probably half of what they were at their recent peak, if not less.
 
My point is just that it's hard to get counts because there's a ton of variation, and it's pretty random. We could get some accurate counts from recent exes, but that only gives us info from that one org from that one time period, not anything that can be applied to other orgs.

i've just found it harder than it seems like it ought to be, to get counts given all the exes and UTRs from various orgs. though maybe i should start a thread and see just what could be gleaned from a concerted effort....

on the other hand i have seen event photos and other information from probably a quarter to a third of the US orgs, so i think i have a pretty good sample to go off of. and i have one or two orgs that i have more detailed insight into, to help understand how things like those photos correspond to actual active membership.

the pattern that's pretty clear and hardly surprising is that orgs in big cities are larger than in smaller ones, and that everything is a bit bigger in Cali as well as in the shadow of Flag, and somewhat smaller across the heartland (pretty much everything between the coasts). the remaining missions, which are more sensitive to actual market conditions, also follow that pattern -- and about two thirds of them, are in California.

i'm reasonably sure that the middle two thirds or so of orgs have an average of 3 to 4 dozen active members remaining, and probably 12 to 15 staff.

here for example is a listing of what was apparently everyone Toronto (metro pop. 6 million) thought they could call on to help with moving into a different building. between 3 and 4 dozen total, many of them long-timers and older:

TorontoUpdate4-e1654569832330.jpg
 
i've just found it harder than it seems like it ought to be, to get counts given all the exes and UTRs from various orgs. though maybe i should start a thread and see just what could be gleaned from a concerted effort....

on the other hand i have seen event photos and other information from probably a quarter to a third of the US orgs, so i think i have a pretty good sample to go off of. and i have one or two orgs that i have more detailed insight into, to help understand how things like those photos correspond to actual active membership.

the pattern that's pretty clear and hardly surprising is that orgs in big cities are larger than in smaller ones, and that everything is a bit bigger in Cali as well as in the shadow of Flag, and somewhat smaller across the heartland (pretty much everything between the coasts). the remaining missions, which are more sensitive to actual market conditions, also follow that pattern -- and about two thirds of them, are in California.

i'm reasonably sure that the middle two thirds or so of orgs have an average of 3 to 4 dozen active members remaining, and probably 12 to 15 staff.

here for example is a listing of what was apparently everyone Toronto (metro pop. 6 million) thought they could call on to help with moving into a different building. between 3 and 4 dozen total, many of them long-timers and older:

TorontoUpdate4-e1654569832330.jpg

Yeah, I hear you. But there's still something like 100 orgs worldwide so we'd need at least that many out/utr people to get a count.

I just think you might be estimating things on the low side. You're only going to get so much info from pictures, they aren't a reliable source of info. Take that picture of Toronto, it says "in the org" across the top, that might just be a list of the people on course that week. If they have 40ish BIS their total field is going to be much bigger than that. I also don't think the pattern of bigger city, bigger org, is true at all. As illogical as it is, you can't base org size off of city size.

A lot of what I say and post is guess work, but I do have actual info on a few orgs at least. The ones I know of are bigger than a dozen staff and 40-50 public. That's all I'm going to say at this time.
 
i've just found it harder than it seems like it ought to be, to get counts given all the exes and UTRs from various orgs. though maybe i should start a thread and see just what could be gleaned from a concerted effort....

on the other hand i have seen event photos and other information from probably a quarter to a third of the US orgs, so i think i have a pretty good sample to go off of. and i have one or two orgs that i have more detailed insight into, to help understand how things like those photos correspond to actual active membership.

the pattern that's pretty clear and hardly surprising is that orgs in big cities are larger than in smaller ones, and that everything is a bit bigger in Cali as well as in the shadow of Flag, and somewhat smaller across the heartland (pretty much everything between the coasts). the remaining missions, which are more sensitive to actual market conditions, also follow that pattern -- and about two thirds of them, are in California.

i'm reasonably sure that the middle two thirds or so of orgs have an average of 3 to 4 dozen active members remaining, and probably 12 to 15 staff.

here for example is a listing of what was apparently everyone Toronto (metro pop. 6 million) thought they could call on to help with moving into a different building. between 3 and 4 dozen total, many of them long-timers and older:

TorontoUpdate4-e1654569832330.jpg


It's certainly one of Scientology's "TOP TEN WITHHOLDS".

The membership numbers of their "religion" and number of staff.

As you observed, it's a lot harder than it should be to discover the simple number of staff that work inside. The info normally would be easily accessible if orgs followed policy and had a posted, updated org board in the publicly viewable area. That would take about 15 seconds to enter the org, look at the org board and just count how many names are on it.

But, no. That's a withhold.

Because they incessantly lie about their "Idea Orgs" and the supposed "huge wins" and "mega success" of their miserably failed expansion program. Even at their ribbon cutting ceremonies, they often quote wildly inflated numbers of how many staff members are now working at the new ideal org. Crazy numbers (over 150! LOL)

It would be "ideal" to get honest info from recently blown staff. But that doesn't seem to be happening with regularity.

A more aggravating way could be done which is to have a surveillance videographer stand near the ideal orgs for a day and simply videotape and COUNT how many staff went inside and then left at the end of the day. My best guestimate is exactly the same range you mentioned (est. 15 or so, perhaps a few more or less)

The pathological LYING about the size of the orgs and the number of Scientologists is an essential element in the mythology of "TOTAL CAUSE" of Operating Thetans. If they have small numbers then there aren't any OTs. It's really that simple.

And they do have really small numbers. But they must never reveal that so that innocent people don't get pneumonia and die, or something like that. LOL


.
 
Last edited:
I didn't have time recently to listen to this one. Am doing it now and so far:

1. Wow, yes if the executives and CLO people have to now spend several hours cleaning and doing decon-7 sprays AN D on top of that do all their usual tasks and all in gloves and masks... yikes! :omg:

I mean inv was already going crazy with inordinate piles of work and overtime... I can't imagine them going through paper files with gloves on and managing everything on time. No way, they must have crashed badly. Everyone must have crashed badly.

2. Holy shit there is STILL no purif going on in summer 2022? :ohmy:

3. PAC base people not being allowed off the base even in clean ship time? Wow.

4. At time stamp 53:54 they are describing EXACTLY that which I predicted would happen way back when I made this February post:

SO has many types of "orders", because you see there's this thing called "command intention" that is seen as an order, but doesn't have to be 100% clear or 100% explicit. That goes against Hubbard's notion of "have everything written down", but SO is full of discrepancies like that.

I'm pretty sure that SO member in question must have had a conversation with the IC in the vein of:

IC: Get your head out of your arse and stop acting like a fucking spastic! Get on with the damn program and get that fucking shot already! You wanna get all of us in trouble?! Did you go PTS or are you simply an imbecile?!

SO member: "No way, that vaccine is dangerous. I ain't doing it until I get written orders signed by the big cheese."

IC: "Fine, be that way. I'm sending you to iso - you can stay there until you rot or get that fucking shot."

And that's exactly what the insider said was happening. "You can get vaccinated, or you can go into quarantine and never be let out until you change your mind."


You know how I would sum up all of scientology's experience with covid?
"Scientology just went through an R-factor."
 
Last edited:
@Karen#1, new interview from "The Insider" is out . . . all about the "Chase Wave" and more.


I listened to it while making dinner and enjoyed it.

The last ten minutes or so . . . there's a sorta astounding, hopeful spoilers. :whistle:

48:00 - 49:00 "It's in the air. You can cut it with a knife." :omg:
 
Last edited:
The pathological LYING about the size of the orgs and the number of Scientologists is an essential element in the mythology of "TOTAL CAUSE" of Operating Thetans. If they have small numbers then there aren't any OTs. It's really that simple.

it also props up the myth of 'expansion' that DM has staked his legitimacy on. i think management doesn't even want the 'public' of local orgs confronting just how shrunken the scene there is, much less realizing that their org is not just a bad apple but more or less typical of the failing state of many other orgs.

but in the new video 'Insider' says about halfway through that despite DM saying that expansion is greater than ever before, in the present moment it's impossible to believe that, and that there's an 'overwhelming preponderance of evidence to contrary' (sorry if i'm ruining any of IL2L's spoiler). i wonder to what extent that really is what's going on; maybe the actual shrinkage, has become too drastic and too obvious to ignore.
 
.

@Karen#1, new interview from "The Insider" is out . . . all about the "Chase Wave" and more.

I listened to it while making dinner and enjoyed it. The last ten minutes or so . . . there's a sorta astounding, hopeful spoilers. :whistle:. 48:00 - 49:00 "It's in the air. You can cut it with a knife." :omg:


.
Terrific insider look at the entertaining reality show of Scientology going "PTS" and "total effect" to the "SP" known as Scientology. The fun enters into it when the planet clearing folks (who claim to have all the solutions to all of life's problems) are shockingly clueless about what do do about their own problems.

The cult has tried everything, but nothing's working!

I wonder what desperately pathetic solution the collapsing cult is going to attempt next. . .


(edited)_BOWLING_2.png


.​
 
Last edited:
.

it also props up the myth of 'expansion' that DM has staked his legitimacy on. i think management doesn't even want the 'public' of local orgs confronting just how shrunken the scene there is, much less realizing that their org is not just a bad apple but more or less typical of the failing state of many other orgs. but in the new video 'Insider' says about halfway through that despite DM saying that expansion is greater than ever before, in the present moment it's impossible to believe that, and that there's an 'overwhelming preponderance of evidence to contrary' (sorry if i'm ruining any of IL2L's spoiler). i wonder to what extent that really is what's going on; maybe the actual shrinkage, has become too drastic and too obvious to ignore.

.

"All good things must come to an end" ​

Even the gaslighting overwhelm & domination of cult parishioners' daily thoughts by Scientology management.

Two years of covid shutdown was a spectacular length of time for battery-powered Scientologists to be away from their spiritual charging stations. Think mobile phone in the wilds of an Amazonian rain forest without a 100 mile long extended charge cord.

Such vast distances and time frames away from the org are not a healthy thing for a cult trying sustain parishioners with blinkless dedicated stares and unquestioning doubt-free minds. Frequent and obligatory attendance to courses, auditing sessions, events and countless "briefings" are tantamount to "booster shots" that safeguard true-believing Scientologists from becoming infected with fatal strains of wog and "enemy line" viruses.

The key to "Keeping Scientology Working" amongst the flock is frequency of refresher implants and the downloading of updated psychic software patches as well as having the faithful upload all-new-and-improved mental operating systems.

Without all those insidiously relentless control mechanisms, the average Scientologist is supremely susceptible to distancing, doubting, defying and even (gasp!) disconnecting from the religious thrall in which they were being held in suspension for so very long.

"The thrall is gone"




.​
 
Last edited:
it also props up the myth of 'expansion' that DM has staked his legitimacy on. i think management doesn't even want the 'public' of local orgs confronting just how shrunken the scene there is, much less realizing that their org is not just a bad apple but more or less typical of the failing state of many other orgs.

but in the new video 'Insider' says about halfway through that despite DM saying that expansion is greater than ever before, in the present moment it's impossible to believe that, and that there's an 'overwhelming preponderance of evidence to contrary' (sorry if i'm ruining any of IL2L's spoiler). i wonder to what extent that really is what's going on; maybe the actual shrinkage, has become too drastic and too obvious to ignore.

I haven't had a chance to watch this yet, but I think it's going to be a big shock as orgs open back up. They might be able to keep up the illusion of expansion in a few areas (CW/LA) but most orgs are going to be desolate wastelands compared to their recent years.

This has been talked about before, but Covid at least gives them an excuse as to why the crash happened. They can just wave their hands and say Covid did it. The reality is the crash was already happening before Covid hit, as the Chase wave was blowing up.

Orgs that had a busy HGC and fullish course rooms are now empty with one or two PCs. I know of a few orgs that were delivering 300+ WDAHs a week (HGC + Purif, not including SRD) and now they're delivering well under 100. Similar numbers across the board, GI, VSD, etc. Stats are 1/3 to 1/5 of what they were during peak Chase wave if I had to estimate, and even that may be high.
 
i'm reasonably sure that the middle two thirds or so of orgs have an average of 3 to 4 dozen active members remaining, and probably 12 to 15 staff.
The idea that it should take 12 to 15 staff to deal with 3 to 4 dozen public is ludicrous.

That many could be (and 40 years ago, often was) handled by a (trained) husband and wife field auditor team working out of their homes.
 
The idea that it should take 12 to 15 staff to deal with 3 to 4 dozen public is ludicrous.

That many could be (and 40 years ago, often was) handled by a (trained) husband and wife field auditor team working out of their homes.

that's keeping the org open over what are really 2 or 3 shifts (days, evenings and weekends) but still. as i've said before, it seems the orgs are the new missions...reverting, not advancing....

another thing i can never get any straightforward answer about, is what however many staff their really are at the orgs, actually do. i can imagine that there is a massive amount of bureaucratic, almost ritual or even anal compulsive make-work, but i'd like to see it actually laid out in detail.
 
The idea that it should take 12 to 15 staff to deal with 3 to 4 dozen public is ludicrous.

That many could be (and 40 years ago, often was) handled by a (trained) husband and wife field auditor team working out of their homes.

12 staff servicing 48 public? Hey, that's a good ratio. Whatever that orgs doing, copy it! The staff to public ratio is increasingly becoming ridiculous. I think for most orgs it's close to 1:2, so you'd have 20 staff servicing 40 public per week. That might even be considered good.

that's keeping the org open over what are really 2 or 3 shifts (days, evenings and weekends) but still. as i've said before, it seems the orgs are the new missions...reverting, not advancing....

another thing i can never get any straightforward answer about, is what however many staff their really are at the orgs, actually do. i can imagine that there is a massive amount of bureaucratic, almost ritual or even anal compulsive make-work, but i'd like to see it actually laid out in detail.

I'll try and give a more detailed answer sometime when I have more time. My quick answer, they write a lot of letters and make a lot of calls. All of which results in no real product. In an org with 20 staff you might only have 5 or so actually producing something, and 5 might be high.
 
I'm not done listening to it yet, I agree with everything he's saying but I want to make a few notes.

In my observation he's correct that there are essentially three areas where Scientologists have been donating money. IAS, buildings, and services. Increasingly services has been a smaller and smaller amount, with more going to the IAS and buildings. But from what I recall the chase wave stuff was mainly for service donations.

He mentions the chase wave starting around 2013-2014 when LA switched to SO. I do think this is when it began being exported all over the world and spread to every org. But in my opinion a lot of the techniques came from Ideal Org regging. It may have been refined and performed with more finesse once LA org started doing it on a widespread basis, but Ideal org regging was using all the shady techniques way before LA opened. So I don't think it spread from LA org to Ideal org regging, it was the other way around if anything. But maybe once LA org had perfected the technique it then bounced back to the Ideal org regges.

The logic behind LA being turned into an SO org, what I remember hearing was that it was supposed to be the model Ideal Org internationally. Each cont. was kind of supposed to have a "continental" ideal org that served as a model for the continent. NY for EUS, LA for WUS, Denmark for EU, etc. This wasn't really super successful, so they turned LA into the model Ideal org, on this planet. Like he said, it was absolutely used to justify everything. Look how well LA is doing, obviously the Ideal org program works and so does everything else. They do so well because they properly use CF, all you need to do is write enough letters to CF and you too can make 500K a week. This is an acceptable truth, especially because it mirrors what LRH says.

As far as Scientology going off a cliff, the more I think about it I think Scientology went off the cliff some time ago. Maybe as far back as the mission massacre. As soon as Scientology stopped getting in new members it started dying. I do think its death has sped up in recent years, and as the hardcore members get older and contribute less, it will only die faster. I am not that optimistic about being able to speed up its death or cause a bunch of people to walk out. I think the people who are left are the hardcore ones and they won't be affected by even a small group renouncing Scientology. But as Scientology relies more and more on the 2nd gen people they will have a rough time, the 2nd gen people just aren't as dedicated and willing to throw their life away.

There was podcast posted on reddit, I'll try to link it sometime. Nothing revelatory in it, but I think it was a good example of what I'm talking about when I say the 2nd gen people are just not as into it. He had grown up in Scientology, did childrens courses, had done some auditing, etc. Then he gets on LA orgs radar and they get him there and crush sell him to take out a 10K loan for services. This basically freaks him out and then he's gone, if I'm remembering things correctly. I think this is a good case study for many 2nd gens, they have done some Scientology and consider themselves Scientologists, then they do a stint in the SO or on staff, or get regged and see what Scientology is really about. After that they decide they don't want to have anything more to do with it and they're out, maybe not publicly but you won't see them on services or even at events.

I also think its interesting how many people we have coming out recently. Katherine Olson, this insider, whoever leaked the audio from the event, the NY leak, etc. Maybe some of this is the same person, but it seems like we at least have a few recently leaking info.
 
Here's a very basic set of staff posts that usually are filled:

ED
D/ED
FBO
LRH Comm
HES
OES
PES
HCO Area Sec (HAS)
Ethics Officer
Reg
Bookstore Officer (maybe)
Treasury Sec
Tech Sec
Dir of Tech Services
Dir of Processing
Dir of Training
Course Supe
Auditor(s)
C/S
Qual Sec
Public Contact Sec
Public Services Sec
Basic Course Supe

So right there you have 23 people.

With fewer staff likely the Tech div dept heads would be missing with the Tech Sec holding all from above
The HES might hold HAS from above although there is usually a lot of pressure to have a HAS posted. That person might hold E/O from above.
The Public Div secs may be held from above by the PES

There are a lot of other posts available if there are more staff available. An org will usually have a DSA (OSA type) as well.
 
Back
Top