I am sorry

In Catholicism you have the Father (masculine), the Son (Jesus, masculine) and the Holy Spirit or Holy Ghost. The Holy Spirit or Ghost would be experienced as having no gender yet a very real and very "there" Divine Presence. No human being is left out in that experience or interpretation of a Universal Intelligence.

The political and social debate is whether self identifying non gender or trans gender people or the multiple variations thereof deserve special legal privileges and whether the entire public starting with children must be educated or reeducated about gender.

I wonder if @eyanda-u is getting anything out of this. If giving credence to the metaphysical idea of incorporeal sentient beings, I assume he's masculine since it's possible but unlikely that Elron would end up "impinging on" a female human to help him work out his problems. A sincere and humble prayer to "God" for help has allowed who knows how many people to resolve deep personal issues. Maybe eyanda-u could try it.

From a scientific realism and psychoanalytic perspective he's in an altered mental state and giving credence to it compounds the condition. Assuming he's for real I hope he works things out.
 
Last edited:
Ron Hubbard said:
Remember that the basis of this meter is one hundred years old. This is not a new meter. A century this thing has been around.

and as noted above, more sophisticated devices had been tested by trained professionals

as always, the old man was decades behind,
That is mostly true according to the 1907 paper Psychophysical investigations with the galvanometer and pneumograph in sane and insane individuals . I'm not sure how you imagine that "wise or perceptive" had anything to do with the choice of instrumentation, though.

However, in the 1919 Carl Jung textbook Studies in Word Association, the mirror galvanometer is the predominant instrument in the thirteen experimental papers contained in that book with a pneumograph only being mentioned once. That is because it was clearly established in Psychophysical Investigations that the pneumograph gave redundant information.

actually, 'thorough' is the first term i used, to apply to the use by Jung and others, of more complex instrumentation resembling what ultimately turned out to be the most effective forms of modern polygraph, whereas Hubbard just glommed onto something crude and convenient then circulating in the quack pseudoscience communities of the late 40s, and made his further decisions about the equipment based on the outcome of petty disputes and financial considerations.

and the early professional investigators were "wise or perceptive" enough to figure out bit by bit that the equipment didn't really produce the sort of impressive results it initially appeared to and eventually abandon all of it as redundant to a properly trained and perceptive therapist, whereas Hubbard doubled down on his mistakes, and let people who had mistakenly put their trust in him suffer as a result, including those literally subject to various forms of censure and punishment due to misinterpreted and inaccurate meter reads like supposed 'rock slams'.

anyway, can we move any further technical discussion of meters over to one of the threads intended for it, and leave this one to the topics introduced by the OP?
 
pretty much the same as what i think of when presumably straight people claim similar things regarding multiple spirits of presumably the same gender that they identify as. does that answer your question?

if our spirits are in some way eternal, do you think that they are gendered so that they always incarnate in either male or female gendered bodies, or are they gender neutral (which seems implicit, though conveniently avoided, in scientology) -- in which case anyone who believes they had a past life as someone of a different gender, is about as wrong and whacked out as those who think they are presently inhabited by spirits of different genders?

my advice for them is partly encapsulated in my initial response to the OP, and will be further in a response to lotus follow.

p.s. i'd be interested in a sincere and open discussion about this. i don't think it's black and white or ever has been, but i also don't necessarily agree with much of what seems to be popular if not faddish these days, either.

I don't know where you get notions when you say this:

do you think that they are gendered so that they always incarnate in either male or female gendered bodies, or are they gender neutral (which seems implicit, though conveniently avoided, in scientology)​
​

Are you saying that in Scientology the past lives are always male or female? Or that the Scientology belief is that they are always one or the other?

And this:

in which case anyone who believes they had a past life as someone of a different gender, is about as wrong and whacked out as those who think they are presently inhabited by spirits of different genders?​
​
​
What are you saying with these comments? Are you saying that in Scientology if you have a past life of a different gender then one is considered whacked out?
 
What are you saying with these comments? Are you saying that in Scientology if you have a past life of a different gender then one is considered whacked out?

first, i'm asking questions in sincere effort to better understand the construct in scientology, and as people here conceive it.

and then i'm pointing out, to put it in a positive frame rather than a negative one, if you believe -- or at least consider -- that spirits aren't gendered, then is it surprising that someone in a body of one gender might have thoughts and desires about being another gender, or that might even be expectable and not out of the ordinary as part of a cycle of incarnation? or even have buyers' remorse, on a metaphysical scale -- 'bodies in pawn' and all that?
 
first, i'm asking questions in sincere effort to better understand the construct in scientology, and as people here conceive it.

and then i'm pointing out, to put it in a positive frame rather than a negative one, if you believe -- or at least consider -- that spirits aren't gendered, then is it surprising that someone in a body of one gender might have thoughts and desires about being another gender, or that might even be expectable and not out of the ordinary as part of a cycle of incarnation? or even have buyers' remorse, on a metaphysical scale -- 'bodies in pawn' and all that?


Well, I'm asking questions, too.

When you state "though conveniently avoided, in Scientology" that doesn't look like a question. It's a statement. So I'm wondering what your are stating.
 
Well, I'm asking questions, too.

When you state "though conveniently avoided, in Scientology" that doesn't look like a question. It's a statement. So I'm wondering what your are stating.

doesn't Hubbard fail to address the issue of thetans and gender, and whether they are gendered, and how they end up in or select gendered bodies? i think the pretty obvious answer to that is yes, so i'm stating it, but if i'm wrong or don't understand the nuances, then please correct me.

and it is an obvious major point that raises inconvenient questions if you really think about it, isn't it?
 
doesn't Hubbard fail to address the issue of thetans and gender, and whether they are gendered, and how they end up in or select gendered bodies? i think the pretty obvious answer to that is yes, so i'm stating it, but if i'm wrong or don't understand the nuances, then please correct me.

and it is an obvious major point that raises inconvenient questions if you really think about it, isn't it?

No, he addresses it pretty good.

Thetans are genderless. They choose their bodies and lives and parents and families and all that.

I know Scientologists that believe that their daughter was their father, etc.

Many Scientologists are surprised to discover a homosexual pastlife when they're not homosexual currently, etc. This happens pretty fast in auditing especially with overts on the 2D. Technically trained auditors take it in stride having encountered this over and over and over.

There's a Sea Org recruiting policy that discusses that the entirety of the second dynamic (families, children, spouses, etc., of which sex and gender would be part of) aren't native to a thetan. They're assumed roles. Obviously this was written as a ploy to minimize the significance of signing a billion year contract and "giving up" one's family, etc.

Homosexuality from a technical aspect is really just an aberration and not all that. The controversy stems from the writings of Science of Survival relating the tone level of 1.1. Sure. Shocking!! **GASP!!**

But in later books such as 8-8008 or such the tone level of every single thetan is flatlined crashed to below Death. In fact, Death, spiritually, is BEING A BODY. That translates to the current identity politics as being devoid of spirituality...that sort of thing....which it is.

Being a body is the condition that 99.9999% of the human population is in. It's the whole point behind the "operating" in Operating Thetan. To no longer operate as a body. The whole point of processing in most beginning stages is to orient the thetan that it's NOT the body...or the mind, etc. This is the pun intended in the term "raw meat". Not only were they new to Scientology but they operate as the meat body: hence, raw meat. Gender is merely an expression of the sex of the body. Obviously, anything that's immortal that considers its identity as a gender of a meat body is screwed up immensely.

That's the Scientology view AFAIK.
 
Last edited:
Thetans are genderless. They choose their bodies and lives and parents and families and all that.

thanks. then they all consciously choose their gender?

over the trillions of years and however many galaxies, could there be planets they've lived on and races they've been, where gender isn't binary (say like hermaphrodites here on Teegeeack)?

and regardless, if they've fluidly switched back and forth between gender over countless lifetimes, how is homosexuality an aberration, rather than say just a different game from countless previous lifetimes they've decided to go back to playing irrespective of their most recent choice of meat body?
 
thanks. then they all consciously choose their gender?

over the trillions of years and however many galaxies, could there be planets they've lived on and races they've been, where gender isn't binary (say like hermaphrodites here on Teegeeack)?

and regardless, if they've fluidly switched back and forth between gender over countless lifetimes, how is homosexuality an aberration, rather than say just a different game from countless previous lifetimes they've decided to go back to playing irrespective of their most recent choice of meat body?

Hermaphrodite isn't a gender. It's a congenital birth defect.

Homosexuality is a pathology.

If the species practiced homosexuality it's dead...as in no future generations. That's considered not prosurvival: hence, aberration.
 
I answered in another post: His spirit being was connected with my spirit being for some reason before we (re)incarnated. We were like magnets which attract each other and our spirits whirl together. I do not channeling him.

And yes, he was not able to reincarnate in his condition. He was not able to incarnate on his own.

Honestly, I'm still figuring out all these things and yes he wants Scientology back, BUT there is also me. The spirit which led L. Ron Hubbard, which is now inside of me, can not act alone anymore!

Please, I don't use or avoid Scientology words and thought structures. If you want to tell me something, it would be nice if you use normal words or describe what you want to tell. Because I'm not only the spirit who led L. Ron Hubbard. At the moment I act (writing), but of course he hear all things. I know that is for many people difficult to imagine and I tried to forget all these things, but there is also a reason why I'm together with him. I know the dangers, I know why he was acting like that. I'm here to understand why all these things happened and I want that things like that not happen again. I hope you understand my position.

I don't like how to speak to him, because that means that you also speak to yourself in that way. I hope you will find peace with him and with yourself. But I understand you, I haven't found peace with David Miscavige either, it's much harder for me to forgive him. I'm still impressed that Ron Miscavige forgave him. I think he gave me an important impulse for unconditional love. Because, weren't we all not ourselves? Some more, others less.

Thank you Ed8 for your comment. I realized I wasn't treating Ron well either. I was also not seeing him as a "human", I also was seeing him as problem. I treated him very often with condescension. I suddenly realized that. In your post I presented him like a broken and dangerous being I have to care for. But now I find out the key is to treat him as equals. I learnt a lot and he learnt a lot, I have to go in a contact with him on eye height. To think I'm better than him, that was my fallacy.
 
Could you and/or Hubbard tell us anything about wife #2, Sara Northrup?

Can you and/or Hubbard tell us why she was officially erased?

Do you and/or Hubbard really believe she was a Russian secret agent named Komkovadamanov?


LRHBettySideBySide.jpg


*

Is there anything you and/or Hubbard can tell us about wife #3, Mary Sue?

msh_what-to-audit.jpg

1952


hqdefault.jpg


​

It's very interesting what all these post are doing with me. I learn a lot about myself. I was thinking you would ask something different, but ok.
First of all, I felt that I have not so much fun doing something I'm not interest in, but I was curious about what will happen. I was focused on Sara and I felt that Ron is also not so amused doing stuff like that, because it feels like a dog is doing a trick for someone. These words came up: I don't like her - sneaky
I will do something like that not again. It is not feeling right and this is not my interest. My interest is unconscious manipulation created by unconscious thoughts. I'm definitely not here to do fact checks, this is what I learned right now.
There is something I can tell about Mary Sue, but this is an emotional thing, I will tell this one day.
But I realized that I'm not really communicate with Ron and in another post I also said to someone that I also realized that I'm not on eye height with him. That helped me a lot to understand myself. When I communicate with him on eye height things are gettin better, they already do! It helped me a lot to understand this! Even when I did sometimes "nonverbal language" (I don't know the right word for that), because of desperation, I fear it. But slowly I will try it more. I'm more unconscious that I thought.
 
Hermaphrodite isn't a gender. It's a congenital birth defect.

Homosexuality is a pathology.

If the species practiced homosexuality it's dead...as in no future generations. That's considered not prosurvival: hence, aberration.
I decided to look up pathology. Here's the definition from www.dictionary.com

noun, plural pa·thol·o·gies.
1. the science or the study of the origin, nature, and course of diseases.
2. the conditions and processes of a disease.
3. any deviation from a healthy, normal, or efficient condition.

Obviously none of those definitions would be acceptable to anyone in the LGBT++ community so I went to the thesaurus and the only alternative I could see is physiology.

noun
1. the branch of biology dealing with the functions and activities of living organisms and their parts, including all physical and chemical processes.
2. the organic processes or functions in an organism or in any of its parts.

"Homosexuality is a phsyiological condition." as an alternative? Who knows? You can't please all the people all the time.
 
I decided to look up pathology. Here's the definition from www.dictionary.com

noun, plural pa·thol·o·gies.
1. the science or the study of the origin, nature, and course of diseases.
2. the conditions and processes of a disease.
3. any deviation from a healthy, normal, or efficient condition.

Obviously none of those definitions would be acceptable to anyone in the LGBT++ community so I went to the thesaurus and the only alternative I could see is physiology.

noun
1. the branch of biology dealing with the functions and activities of living organisms and their parts, including all physical and chemical processes.
2. the organic processes or functions in an organism or in any of its parts.

"Homosexuality is a phsyiological condition." as an alternative? Who knows? You can't please all the people all the time.


I don't know why pathology isn't accepted other than someone's issue with it.

We all suffer pathologies. Homosexuality is definitely a deviation from a normal condition.

The history to have it normalized reads just like a Scientology ops. That story has, more or less, been excised from the internet.
 
No, that's not what it is. I recognize the name from an ancient language I learned trillions of years ago.

The English translation is "Xenu".


















Sorry, eyanda-u! It was a bad joke but I could not resist. :no: :D

No worry, I didn't understand this joke. I only know it's still a topic for Ron. Almost 3 years ago my body was reacted to that topic, there is something in it, I don' like.
 
I don't know why pathology isn't accepted other than someone's issue with it.

We all suffer pathologies. Homosexuality is definitely a deviation from a normal condition.

The history to have it normalized reads just like a Scientology ops. That story has, more or less, been excised from the internet.
You'll have a hard time convincing "all of us" we have pathologies or are pathological according to the strict definition of the word. Speak for yourself! ...................................................hey - just joking - eyanda is back and it's his thread - it was an interesting diversion
 
It's very interesting what all these post are doing with me. I learn a lot about myself. I was thinking you would ask something different, but ok.

First of all, I felt that I have not so much fun doing something I'm not interest in, but I was curious about what will happen. I was focused on Sara and I felt that Ron is also not so amused doing stuff like that, because it feels like a dog is doing a trick for someone. These words came up: I don't like her - sneaky
I will do something like that not again. It is not feeling right and this is not my interest.

Alright, so the Hubbard spirit is slandering Sara, as usual, and is irrational on the topic of Sara. Well, at least that's consistent.

By the way, from some years back, here's a photo of Sara's daughter (by Hubbard) Alexis' daughter (Hubbard's granddaughter) and her daughter (Hubbard's great grand daughter).

581577_4344165415413_785684437_n-jpg.240119


You might show it to the Ron spirit. They continue to live, despite having been officially erased by him.

[Continuing the Ron spirit's thoughts:] My interest is unconscious manipulation created by unconscious thoughts. I'm definitely not here to do fact checks,

Perhaps if you placed quotes around Hubbard's thoughts it might be easier to understand.

Supposedly, Hubbard's interest was in unleashing the power of "thetans" (spirits), so he seems to have downgraded his interest to the Dianetics 1950-era interest of the unconscious mind.

this is what I learned right now.

Well, thanks.

There is something I can tell about Mary Sue, but this is an emotional thing, I will tell this one day.
But I realized that I'm not really communicate with Ron and in another post I also said to someone that I also realized that I'm not on eye height with him. That helped me a lot to understand myself. When I communicate with him on eye height things are gettin better, they already do! It helped me a lot to understand this! Even when I did sometimes "nonverbal language" (I don't know the right word for that), because of desperation, I fear it. But slowly I will try it more. I'm more unconscious that I thought.

It appears that Hubbard has pretty much gone silent. That's quite a contrast with the original very talkative Hubbard.

Have you considered the possibility that you have one of Hubbard's "Body Thetans," which thinks it's Hubbard but is not?

There's "NOTs" procedure on how to "blow him" (send him away) which you might try.

Assuming you don't do that, I guess you're stuck with him, or whoever it is.

Keep up updated, and let us know how it's going.
 
You know who is sorry?

I am. This is all too stupid for me and whenever Scientology is discussed seriously it quickly becomes stupid - forcing me to feel embarrassed and ashamed that I ever took any of this stupid crap seriously.

If you're not trolling and joking then you are seriously mentally unstable.

Run from the Scientology.

I'm not a troll. I can't tell how stupid I felt, when I went to people and said, well, I'm feeling and thinking like L. Ron Hubbard would do today and I want to find out why. I was feeling like these people who are saying that they are Jesus. So, today I know how it feels and maybe Jesus is a multiple spirit being and can incarnate in many bodys and spread their ideas and energies. I also knew someone who said he was Jesus and I was thinking, okayyyyy.

For that what I'm going through I would say I'm very stable.

Yes, normally I would do so, but in this case I have to change something. I fear David Miscavige, but that means that he is also fearing me. I mean what's way creepier than someone is coming back?
 
I'm not a troll. I can't tell how stupid I felt, when I went to people and said, well, I'm feeling and thinking like L. Ron Hubbard would do today and I want to find out why. I was feeling like these people who are saying that they are Jesus. So, today I know how it feels and maybe Jesus is a multiple spirit being and can incarnate in many bodys and spread their ideas and energies. I also knew someone who said he was Jesus and I was thinking, okayyyyy.

For that what I'm going through I would say I'm very stable.

Yes, normally I would do so, but in this case I have to change something. I fear David Miscavige, but that means that he is also fearing me. I mean what's way creepier than someone is coming back?
"I mean what's way creepier than someone is coming back?" laughter! That's a funny way to say it. Coming back and then coming after you would be creepier. :)

Somewhat in the same category a few years ago I went to a small Psychic Fair and they had a speaker named Christopher DiCesare who had experienced a well documented haunting while he was a student at the State University of New York in Geneseo [a town] in 1985. In some media he even got named "The Ghost Boy of Geneseo". Lol

I chatted with him for a while after his talk. I mentioned that I had once been a Scientologist so maybe that made him feel I wouldn't be skeptical. In his experience there was no way, no how, that anyone was ever going to convince him that the haunting was a figment of his imagination.

Long story short the ghost was starting to attack some of his friends and Chris decided he must take the situation on his own shoulders and he summoned his courage and confronted the ghost and asked it, "What Do You Want!?" Just from memory and maybe not entirely accurate the ghost said something like "Paaaain". Chris then commanded the ghost, "YOU MUST GO!!" and it departed.


Also:


Nice accompanying song - Unfamiliar moon, the stars are out of place, everything is new, everything is changed . . . .
 
Last edited:
As I recall, there have been more than six "Hi! I'm Ron, I'm back" claimants since LRH died.
Curious how they all came out of the woodwork only after there was nobody around who was close to LRH and could call BS on them.
 
Back
Top