Unchanging Scientologists: How to treat?

..

After decades of interacting with all kinds of Hubbardites, I finally discovered the difference between COS Scientologists and INDIE Scientologists:

1. A COS Scientologist refuses to answer your questions because they are afraid of you getting overwhelmed & over-restimulated from being exposed to material about the supreme rulah Xenu.​
​
2. An INDIE Scientologist refuses to answer your questions because they are afraid that they will get overwhelmed & over-restimulated from being exposed to material about the supreme rulah Ron.​
​
.​
 
If you were in the process of making a large investment and I was aware that the individual managing whatever fund or business you were about to invest in was a serial felon, previously convicted of defrauding investors on multiple occasions, would you prefer that I told you about that?
Or should I just let you live your life without interfering? :unsure:

Fair point Type4. With hindsight I suppose I could have at least tried to communicate with them and ask them why they were making this decision, but I don't think there would have been much point frankly. They would have been unlikely to have have listened because I didn't have the altitude to command their respect.

Apart from the fact both had independent Scn practices, at least one was a conventionally trained doctor (I think the other one was too but I'm not sure); both worked in alternative medicine; and they both had families, were considerably older than me and had far more experience of the CofS. Also, by the time I found out about their decision it was a fait accompli and they would have had superiors telling them to cut the "entheta comm line."

I only came across them in the first place because I had left the CofS and was scouting around for places I could go to get audited, and I didn't know them very well.
 
Last edited:
My assessment is just the opposite. After years of being here and on ESMB I've yet to see any display of respect or politeness.

Many only see whatever suits their fixated opinions. Confirmation bias is a thing.

What I've seen is accusations and vitriol - most of the time it's him interjecting when he was never included or invited.

I'm sorry, when did the owner/operator of these forums, @PirateAndBum, grant you authority to determine who may or may not comment on any public post or thread ?
 
Last edited:
It seems to me that there is a lack of information from independent scientologists as to why they still use the word "scientology" to describe what they are doing. I am not criticising anyone here, simply trying to understand this situation.

I suppose some readers are going to find this comment somewhat assholish, but it is what it is:

Somebody who left a religious group does not get to determine who is or is not validly practicing the religion of that group. Neither do they get to determine for someone else what is or is not a valid religion.

Sure, you all may have strong opinions about that, but why on God's green Earth should any of us care ?
 
Last edited:
Just as one example, many Scientologists believe that auditing can handle any physical issue, such as cancer, and as a result, they discount the value of getting treatment in time, believing that their cancer will be fully handled with auditing. Many more examples can be provided for non-medical issues as well.

Well, in the United States, the U.S. Constitution (First Amendment Establishment Clause) enshrines a right for someone to believe things other folks consider stupid or even dangerous as part of a religion.

Certainly, one may exercise their right to Free Speech to tell some other folks that they reckon those beliefs are stupid or dangerous. I wouldn't dream of questioning that. But that is as far as one's Free Speech rights extend when they collide with another's Religious Belief rights.

What you may not do is in any way attempt to infringe their right of belief or practice whether by using physical duress, psychological duress or whatever. At that point, the effort becomes a Civil Rights violation and the U.S. Courts have said so rather consistently.


However, commission of statute crimes in violation of State or Federal codes of law is not protected by the First Amendment.

So one cannot be - for example - a worshipper of Baal and sacrifice babies to a flaming statue. Warren Jeffs found out that he cannot f*ck half a dozen different underage minors just because he believes in old school Mormonism. And we must all hold out hope that David "Darth Midget" Miscavige is going to soon learn he does not have unlimited rights to commit financial crimes, torture people, etc, either.
 
Last edited:
I suppose some readers are going to find this comment somewhat assholish, but it is what it is:

Somebody who left a religious group does not get to determine who is or is not validly practicing the religion of that group. Neither do they get to determine for someone else what is or is not a valid religion.

Sure, you all may have strong opinions about that, but why on God's green Earth should any of us care ?
.

There would be substantially LESS people considering your comments "asshole-ish" (your term) if you didn't hide behind the concept of "valid religion". Nobody cares what religion you are but if you are going to step forward and aggressively crusade and campaign for your religious rights and try to shoot down those who are vocal about considering Scientology a vicious fraud and hoax, you'd inspire more respect—IF YOU ARE TRANSPARENT ABOUT WHAT EXACTLY YOUR "RELIGION" BELIEVES AND DOES.

However, you routinely REFUSE to answer what your "religious beliefs" are and nastily rebuff anyone who asks you specific questions about Xenu and a long list of other magical claims that the "religion" of Scientology claims. You get very indignant, offended and downright mean if someone dares ask you what your religious beliefs are exactly.

How in hell do you expect and demand people to respect your "religion" if you treat them like an asshole for merely asking you what your religious beliefs are. The answer to that question is not "NONE OF YOUR GODDAMN BUSINESS!" LOL.

Just because someone invokes the word "religion" doesn't mean that they are entitled to any respect or to demanding that people shut up when they are asked questions about their religion. Under your theory, simply saying the word "religion" aloud is supposed to automatically afford you religious protections. Unfortunately your theory has historically been debunked more times than can be counted in the last 2000 years. Jim Jones wanted "religious" protections too, but he never explained what his religion was until 918 people died in the Jonestown massacre sponsored by the religion known as "THE PEOPLE'S TEMPLE".

I personally don't care what you do or don't believe. But don't expect a free pass to patrol the website correcting everyone when you yourself never disclose what your "religion" is exactly. Every "Indie" Scientologist I have spoken to has a different and unique opinion about what their religion is. Many do not even consider it a religion but still mistakenly think it is a "modern science".

Do you believe that "Indie Scientology" is a religion?

Does your religion believe in any of the OT III material? How about the "wholetrack incidents" from the book History Of Man and countless Hubbard lectures where he described Gorilla Goal Implants and other quadrillion year old creation theories?

If you don't care to reveal what your religious beliefs are, no problem. But don't then talk about your "religion" when nobody has a clue what you are talking about.

Get the point? Or is the mere fact of me asking for clear answers to simple questions an act of religious bigotry and hate speech?


.
 
Last edited:
Sneaks support of Scientology's fraudulent, and its pointy, religion angle shows that his indoctrination in Scientology occurred after Miscavige assumed power.

Before Miscavige, only the most naive members truly believed Scn was a a religion.
 
Last edited:
The steps on and off the Bridge:

1. Pre Scientologist ("wog")

2. "Raw meat" Scientologist

3. Scientologist

4. Independent Scientologist (optional)

5. Ex Scientologist

We've watched many pass through these stages? But what to do when someone is stalled?

Be confrontational?

Be friendly?


Ignore

?
​
Moving out of Scientology requires the ability to observe, confront and think.

People who are stuck suffer lack of one or more of these.
 
Sneaks support of Scientology's fraudulent, and its pointy, religion angle

Oh, you are - again - very much mistaken. I don't support the organizational legal gymnastics "religion angle" and never did.

The subject itself is a "religion" for any person who believes that its study and practice are the road to their spiritual salvation. A religion is incredibly personal.

Official corporate Scientology has a membership who, for the most part, have adopted Scientology (the subject) as their personal religion. There is nothing you all can do ever about that. We have, among the Independents and Freezoners, a good many people who regard the subject itself as their personal religion. Maybe more outside the official church than inside by this point. Hard to say.

This fact is the exact reason the official corporate "church" passes muster with the U.S. I.R.S. as an "organization formed for a religious purpose". However, if you really want to take away that 501 (c) 3 corporate income tax exemption, it doesn't actually matter that Scientology, the subject is a religion for the membership and for so many Independents.

All that is necessary is obtaining proof that David "Darth Midget" Miscavige and/or any other Scientology corporate officials are running that organization for their own personal profit. If you focus on obtaining that dirt and then handing it over the I.R.S., the exemption can be made to go away. That comes from Mike Rinder, former Commanding Officer OSA INT.

By the way, the I.R.S. notion that Ron Hubbard was running C of S for his own personal profit is what killed the C of S of California corporate income tax exemption back in 1963 (?), IIRC.

I'm not sure exactly how much financial damage removing their corporate income tax exemption would do to official corporate Scientology, but it seems to me that it ought to be substantial as this should eliminate tax deductions for contributions to the I.A.S. (the bottomless legal slush fund). The biggest issue is would be digging up the necessary evidence, I expect.
 
Last edited:
Sneaks support of Scientology's fraudulent, and its pointy, religion angle shows that his indoctrination in Scientology occurred after Miscavige assumed power.

Before Miscavige, only the most naive members truly believed Scn was a a religion.

.
Naturally, like most members of this board, when I was active in Scientology I thought it was a cringey joke that Hubbard tried to force the tax dodge concept of "religion" on his "modern science". Everyone I knew and worked with just kind of closed their eyes and shook their head a brief moment, just before thinking "whatever!" and went back to work. It was an embarrassment.

Later when Hubbard suddenly ordered everyone to do the ministers course and become "ordained" I just cringed and thought, "no f'ing wayyyyy!" Soon I found myself on course with other staff members reading a paperback of that book, what was the title? "Great Religions of the World" or something like that? I could barely read the pages or understand what the hell i had just read--such was my repulsion at having to pretend to be interested in other religions or becoming a minister. I don't even think i finished reading the book and never did anything else on the Minister's Course checksheet. I somehow escaped and nobody ever mentioned it again. Probably because there was a newer and better "vital" project that all staff had to do immediately, LOL.

Years and years later I heard the word "religion" the next time when a business associate and friend of mine (who was a devout Christian) joined Scientology and began to get equally gung-ho about Ron as he previous did about Jesus. Then one day in casual conversation he uttered the words "my religion" (referring to Scientology) and I almost burst out laughing because i thought he had suddenly developed a keen wit and satirical flair. I looked at him while pausing---and then realized he was dead serious. Internally I shook my disbelieving head again. My actual thought was "WTF happened to YOU?!" Probably like seeing a friend return from war with half their face blown off and you have to pretend everything is normal.

The next time i heard it was decades and decades later on ESMB. In the first year or two i was here, Alanzo was one of the respected critics of Scientology. Then he started to run his "crusades" and he became obnoxiously out of touch, to the point it was painful to listen to his bizarre non-sequitur rants and idiotic theories. Then it happened. One day he uttered the words "....my religion" in one of his sermons and i stopped dead cold and thought. WAITTTTTT!!! DID HE JUST SAY "MY RELIGION?!!!"

I went back and read it a few times just to make sure I wasn't hallucinating.

Yup he said t hat.

I asked him about it but he would not answer.

That was the moment Alanzo jumped the shark. He went into a steep steep steep decline after that moment and became a toxic troll and got banned.

He came back much later and got banned again.

Then he came back again on this message board (redux) and got banned again.

Very curious, he jumped the shark at the moment he started spewing the "my religion" stuff.

And naturally from that point Alanzo ended up being a cult shill, performing fair game trolling against ex-scientologists on a full time basis.

That's why whenever I hear a Scientologist or an Indie start talking about "their religion" i stop whatever i am doing and look up in disbelief.

How anyone in Scientology or Indie Scientology would NOT know that calling Scientology a "religion" is a total joke is one of the world's great mysteries. Even when i was a hard core Scientologist and on staff, I knew that "my religion" was the punchline to a joke.

Now with the internet, how could someone not get the joke? LOL


.
 
Last edited:
.

Certainly, one may exercise their right to Free Speech to tell some other folks that they reckon those beliefs are stupid or dangerous. I wouldn't dream of questioning that. But that is as far as one's Free Speech rights extend when they collide with another's Religious Belief rights.

You wouldn't dream of questioning someone's beliefs if they were dangerous? LOL. That positively reeks of virtue signaling.

You talk the talk, let's see if you walk the walk. . .

If you knew a member of the religious cult called "THE MANSON FAMILY" or knew a member of "THE PEOPLE'S TEMPLE" and you knew that their cult was extraordinary dangerous by reason of their leader being a psychotic. . . you wouldn't dream of questioning their beliefs in an effort to get them out before they were in prisons or dead?

You'd rather let the individual's life be destroyed just you you can have the status-boosting bragging rights that you are a religious man with such infallible integrity that you would never question anyone else's beliefs, even if they were on a death trajectory---or possibly going to go out into the night hunting with sharpened butcher knives along with the Manson crew?


..
 
Last edited:
I have no issue with anyone presenting complete, accurate and unembellished verified true facts in an attempt to persuade anyone to drop their support for the corporate C of S and their institutionalized atrocities.

There exist an abundance of facts which meet all those qualifications about: Ron Hubbard, the official corporate Church of Scientology, David "Darth Midget" Miscavige and his Sea Ogre cult fanatics that it should never be necessary to alter, embellish or outright fabricate any false facts for this purpose. Half-Truths are Whole Lies.
If you were in the process of making a large investment and I was aware that the individual managing whatever fund or business you were about to invest in was a serial felon, previously convicted of defrauding investors on multiple occasions, would you prefer that I told you about that?
Or should I just let you live your life without interfering? :unsure:
Some people A) won't take your advice B) Will listen to your advice and do what they want to anyway C) Don't want to hear any advice, especially from you (wives and husbands fit this to a tee) D) will only listen to authority, even if the authority is saying exactly what you said.
I learned the hard way, those four.

Am I pessimistic? No - I am stunned when somebody actually does what I suggest. I just learned to accept the old adage: opinions are like assholes, everybody has one.

Mimsey
 
.
You wouldn't dream of questioning someone's beliefs if they were dangerous? LOL. That positively reeks of virtue signaling.

I'll give you some genuine virtue signaling: it is best not to post while under the influence of alcohol or mind-altering drugs. Thank you.
 
When I got into scientology it was through reading DMSMH and I assumed it was a self-help system. After I'd been going to my local org for a week or so I was becoming increasingly nervous about references I was seeing about religion. One day I asked the ED if scientology was a religion and he assured me it wasn't. He said that referring to it as a religion was just a pretense to keep the government off their backs, or some such thing. That handled my considerations so I stayed for the next 15 years. Doh!
 
Some people A) won't take your advice B) Will listen to your advice and do what they want to anyway C) Don't want to hear any advice, especially from you (wives and husbands fit this to a tee) D) will only listen to authority, even if the authority is saying exactly what you said.
I learned the hard way, those four.

Am I pessimistic? No - I am stunned when somebody actually does what I suggest. I just learned to accept the old adage: opinions are like assholes, everybody has one.

Mimsey

I studied Vernon Howard's materials for a while and I still remember a comment he made in one of his tapes ("The Horror In Anytown") about giving advice to people (meaning other adults);

Never give advice to someone unless;

1 / he or she asks for it, and

2 / he or she follows your advice.

I think this is sound advice, though I can't say I always follow it.
 
Back
Top