Hubbard became an "implanter" in September 1963.

I figured what the hell, and received the intensive, since whoever's time track I would be experiencing, at least it would be an interesting show of ancient facsimiles of some kind. At the time, auditing was only 25 dollars an hour (soon to be fifty). In retrospect, I should have purchased a quarter pound of high quality marijuana with the money.

Well, I think you have figured out the connections between ancient facsimiles, marijuana and ancient aliens. ;)

explained-i7849.jpg
 
interesting account, thanks for that.

i would say it's an example of how such things are driven by cultural archetypes. if you were auditing someone from South Asia they might come up with an incident from the divisive early history of Buddhism (virtually unknown to westerners), or say something from Hindu history and mythology.

which reminds me, i want to make the point again, that if there is any validity to remembrances of past lives, you have to consider that models like the Akashic Record or a collective memory are probably better ones -- simpler mechanisms, and better explain how many people connect to the same notable historical figures, while individual cases when closely scrutinized often turn out to involve lives that would have had to have actually overlapped (say a solder who died in WW1, and a 20s flapper -- the date math conflicts if you stop and think about it). Hubbard, not surprisingly, chose the most ego-centric model.


The overlap aspect isn't at all inconsistent with Scientology dogma. The problem lies with illiterate and untrained Scientologists that aren't familiar with Hu666ard's BS on the topic.

First of all, there's plenty of material about multiple bodies, bodies in pawn, etc. Then there's plenty of material about thetan's snipping facsimiles similar to grabbing trading cards, etc. There's plenty of material yacking about doing the same with bodies - snatching, blanketing, snipping - I can't remember all of it. Then there's material that says taking on a body doesn't have to correspond with birth/death or any set interval which ties into what I just wrote before this. Doing a bunk, etc.

Finally, though, there's the whole Xenu thing. And that's that you're a composite being with softened up theta entities injected into you. You can think of it as an insane asylum where you have all these somnolent amnesiacs that have been imprisoned into a conglomerate full of perverts, criminals, non conformists and, wow! how fortunate, "artists". The body, itself, is comprised of solid ridges of thetans that have degraded and died to the point that they've become MEST. The whole implication is that we're sentenced here to die to become MEST - which includes the pixels in this type that you're reading. They're dead thetans. Scientologists are the top 1% but that's the top 1% of the long gone dead with one foot in the grave or something like that...I can't remember the specific verbiage. These softened up injected entities are all overlapped with intentions, goals and all that. What you think are your thoughts, intentions and goals are anything but. You're buried under this mass of psycho. It's all stimulus-response circuits and bank and reactive automaticities - (this is how Hu666ard makes it so you can't even trust your own thinking - which means when you want to route off of staff because of the abuse it's actually "bank" thought and "succumb postulates" and, basically, not you). When you have a muscle spasm that's one of these dead and dying entities moving. They come in clusters, etc.

They're all going to share "the bank". That's the only thing we have in common. When there's a consensus, especially, it's bank agreement - completely reactive. An implant.

This is what FPRD is all about and what the OT levels are all about and what "Total Freedom" is all about but it's, essentially, releasing the actual thetan from this prison thing.

Any past life material is, basically, coming from this prison/psych ward conglomerate that the thetan is ensnarled/imprisoned in.

Most of what I just wrote is discernible from the basic blue bound Scientology books which are fast and easy reads and, most likely, exist in pdf formats all over the web.

If you're interested to understand what the BS is.

But it's in this way that Scientologist view the world and "raw meat". Raw meat is so far downscale that they have zero clue what's "reality" and need to be "handled" so that they can be saved in spite of themselves. Registrars will reg your last single dime because they're salvaging you from this whole thing. This is why they'll poison your dog and send dildos to your employer and all sorts of Fair Game crimes. This is why an SP Declare is so devastating. This is why all the NOW!, NOW!, NOW! because you can degrade to where you can't operate a body anymore.

Scientologists view laws, rules, governments, news, reporters, psychs, education, religion, science and everything and anything not L. Ron through this lens. Laws are just stimulus response dead and dying imprisoned amnesiac perverts/criminals entities creations - basically a "you" in a body as it is right now is a plurality of an untold massive amount of amnesiac and dead and dying theta entities - to say nothing of the GE lines, etc. Not only that but they're imprisoned in chains of facsimiles from implants and many of these they've snipped and stolen and traded. They're (laws) not analytical...they're reactive and insane. They're the products of circuits and implants.

Scientology is the ONLY thing that's not bank upon bank upon bank upon bank. This is the dwindling spiral. The only way out of this is to EXACTLY follow the taped route out as discovered by the GREATEST SALVAGER EVER - L. Ron - Mankind's Greatest Friend!

The fact that you're running past deaths/incidents that overlap is entirely consistent with Scientology doctrine.

If anyone is of the mind that there's one thetan with one life and one body then they are way off the mark with Scientology. You can "grok" all this by merely reading things like FOT, 8-8008, 8-80, Have You Lived Before?, History of Man - I don't remember all the specifics but they're short and fast and easy reads and you can read one of them in a day, easily. They're Scientology basics and blue bounds and if you read it I'm sure the info is spread across them but it's there.
 
Last edited:
Just to follow up on what I just posted this material was, for the most part, released in 1952 in 8-80 and History of Man (What to Audit). I haven't dug too much into anything else but I'm certain that if you read Fundamentals of Thought, 8-8008, Have You Lived Before? and the other Scientology basic books that there'll be more and more of this stuff referenced and all that.

This is from HOM:

INJECTED ENTITIES are the third class of target. These are actually synthetics. They​
are ridges that “think”. They form a very complex pattern. They have geographical areas in the​
body. These areas are standard, preclear to preclear. These areas answer up on an E-meter like​
actual minds rather than compartments of a mind. The areas are the CENTRE (forehead and​
down), the RIGHT INSIDE (from the edge of the jaw halfway out to the shoulder), the​
RIGHT OUTSIDE (from halfway to the shoulder to the point of the shoulder) the LEFT​
INSIDE (opposite from the right inside), the LEFT INSIDE (opposite from the right inside),​
the LEFT OUTSIDE (opposite from the right outside), the STOMACH ENTITY (located in the​
area of the solar plexus), plus various other entities held in by these basic entities. These​
entities run off their own past deaths, on other tracks, hold sections of the body paralysed, bar​
areas from being audited, withhold information from “I” and do other mischief. They are​
actually the basis of “demon circuits” (as covered in DIANETICS: THE MODERN SCIENCE​
OF MENTAL HEALTH) and they mirror the personality of persons antipathetic to the preclear​
They are entirely stimulus-response. Each one has, from preclear to preclear, the same​
personality in the same body position. The RIGHT INSIDE, for instance, answers up to the​
name of “crew chief”. They are male and female. Their source is probably a “softened-up” theta​
being and they disappear when electronic incidents are audited. Prior to their disappearance,​
they can exhibit a wonderful and awesome role in confusing the preclear. The auditor can move​
the attention of the preclear into one of these and audit it through a death or painful experience​
and so bring it up to present time. In view of the fact that auditing basic electronic incidents​
eradicates them, little attention need be paid to them by the auditor beyond knowing that they​
are there, that they are the “mysterious voices” in the heads of some preclears, that they make​
critical or commanding remarks to him and serve, in general, as a fine source of aberration.​
Paralysis, anxiety stomachs, arthritis and many ills and aberrations have been relieved by​
auditing them. An E-meter shows them up and makes them confess their misdeeds. They are​
probably just compartments of the mind which, cut off, begin to act as though they were​
persons. Here is an inexhaustible source of study and speculation which I leave to another,​
having located the method of wiping them out without paying any attention to them.​
​
THETA BEINGS are the fourth and only really important target for the auditor. The​
theta being is the “I”, it is WHO the preclear is. If all the entities and beingnesses of the preclear​
were hydrogen balloons locked up inside him and each had a name and identity, the auditor​
might be confused and the preclear IS confused as to who “I” is. But if the preclear were​
suddenly opened and the balloons let loose, the “I” balloon would float free clear and​
unmistakable and that “I” balloon would be the theta being, it would be who the preclear​
always thought he was anyway. All others are simply modifiers. The theta being does not get​
lost. It does not go away, it cannot be stolen. If it went away, the preclear would be with it and​
be it. The vagueness of personal identity is caused by the confusion of the theta being, not its​
“inextricable” tanglement with other identities.​
​
The theta being can be confused in itself, it can be hypnotised, it can go to sleep. It can​
experience emotions. It can think. It can feel pain. It is immortal in that it cannot die—but it​
could possibly become so burdened with facsimiles that it could not continue along with​
bodies. It does not need a body to think, make facsimiles, experience emotions, remember or​
perceive.​
​
​
It goes on from there. Notice that injected entities are "ridges that think". Notice that they're "probably a 'softened-up' theta being".

This is from 8-80:

One does not audit engrams with the thetan. He blows ridges to which are fastened​
thousands of engrams. This is very fast auditing. Ridges are blown by locating them and​
turning them white. If they don’t blow at first glance, get the flow in and the flow out from​
the thetan, alternating it, until the ridge is continually gray or white and, by shifting flows,​
keep it so until it is gone. After flowing gray or white in one direction for a short time, a​
ridge goes black. Then the flow is reversed and the ridge goes white or gray again. If it then​
turns black, once more reverse the flow. The ridges can act like beings when sprayed with​
energy or when permitted to give off energy. These are the “demon circuits of the mind”.​

This is from earlier in the book that describes ridges comprising the MEST body:

Body Ridges pic 8-80.JPG


In the same book it gives the Tone Scale where a dead thetan is Being a Body. Those ridges, then, are dead thetans, injected entities, demon circuits and the various balloons that swamp and bury the thetan.

The reason your preclear is fixed to a MEST body lies in his inability to produce​
energy enough to know and to get away from one.​
​
His career with bodies is as follows:​
​
He hurt them by accident first.​
Then he hurt them without understanding they hurt by using their sexual emotion.​
Then he blamed them and said and felt he would have no responsibility for them.​
Then he felt the emotion of no-sympathy for them.​
Then he felt sympathy.​
He began to propitiate.​
He wanted to make amends.​
He was a MEST body. *​
​
Run the beauty and ugliness of these.​
​
The cycle of no-sympathy-equals-sympathy is inevitable. That for which we declare​
no-sympathy today will receive our sympathy tomorrow.​
​
If you have a preclear sight some old body well before him and feel no-sympathy for​
it, he then will feel no-sympathy, sympathy, propitiation, and suddenly, he IS the body.​
​
One runs facsimiles on the body partly because the body is an electrical ground,​
partly because it has been assigned responsibility.​
​
The thetan assigning responsibility to the body then becomes the body. This is a​
general principle. One becomes that to which he assigns responsibility too often and too long.​
He makes it Cause and, at last, to be Cause himself, he must be the thing.​
​
People imagine they are in bodies because they are hiding from something and many​
other reasons. But these are not important. The important thing is that bodies were handy to​
have, once. They were fun.​
​
This process, as itself, as simple as it is, will eventually detach one from his body.​
After that he can use it or not as he chooses.​
​


Then this, here:

Below zero on the tone scale is applicable only to a thetan.​
​
It has been quite commonly observed that there are two positions for any individual​
on the tone scale. This occurs because there is a position for the composite of the thetan plus​
his MEST body operating in a state of unknowingness that he is not a MEST body, and​
behaving according to social patterns, which give him some semblance of sanity. The other​
position on the tone scale is the position of the thetan himself, and it is necessary for us to​
demonstrate a negative scale in order to find the thetan at all.​
​
Being a Body Death Tone Scale pic 8-80.JPG​
This sub-zero tone scale shows that the thetan is several bands below knowingness as​
a body and so he will be found in the majority of cases. In our homo sapiens he will be​
discovered to be below zero on the tone scale. The zero to four plus tone scale was​
formulated on, and referred to, bodies and the activity of thetans with bodies. In order, then,​
to discover the state of mind of the thetan, one must examine the sub-zero scale. He has some​
trained patterns as a body which make it possible for him to know and to be. As himself, he​
has lost all beingness, all pride, all memories, and all self-determined ability, but yet has an​
automatic response-mechanism in himself which continues furnishing his energy.​
​
EACH ONE OF THE ABOVE POINTS ON THE SCALE IS RUN AS POSITIVE​
AND NEGATIVE. Example: The beautiful sadness of needing bodies. The beautiful sadness​
of NOT needing bodies. The beauty of being responsible for bodies, the beauty of NOT being​
responsible for bodies. Each one is run as itself and then as the reverse with the addition of​
NOT.​
​
The sub-zero to 40.0 scale is the range of the thetan. A thetan is lower than body​
death, since it survives body death. It is in a state of knowingness below 0.375 only when it is​
identifying itself as a body and IS, to its own thinking, the body. The BODY-PLUSTHETAN​
scale is from 0.0 to 4.0 and the position on this scale is established by the social​
environment and education of the composite being and is a stimulus-response scale. The​
preclear is initially above this 0.375 on the BODY-PLUS-THETAN RANGE. Then, on​
auditing, he commonly drops from the FALSE TONE of the BODY-PLUS-THETAN scale​
and into the true tone of the thetan.​
​
This is actually the only self-determined tone present— the actual tone of the thetan.​
From this sub-zero he quickly rises up scale through the entire range as a thetan and generally​
settles at 20.0 and in command of the body and situations. The course of auditing then takes​
the preclear, quite automatically, down from the FALSE TONE of the BODY-PLUSTHETAN​
SCALE to the actual tone of the thetan. Then the tone of the thetan rises back up​
the scale level by level.​
​
It is not uncommon to find the preclear (who IS the thetan) quite raving mad under​
the false “veneer” of social and educational stimulus-response training and to discover that​
the preclear, while behaving quite normally in the BODY-PLUS-THETAN state, becomes​
irrational in the course of auditing. BUT DESPITE THIS, the preclear is actually being far​
more sane and rational than ever before and the moment he discovers himself as himself, as​
THE source of energy and personality and beingness of a body, he becomes physically and​
mentally better. Thus the auditor must not be dismayed at the course of tone, but should​
simply persevere until he has the thetan up into rational range. A raving mad thetan is far​
more sane than a normal human being. But then, as you audit, observe it for yourself.​



That's enough for me for a long time to come but this is just from 8-80 and History of Man from 1952. It's the whole Xenu story right here and I'm sure it's spread across the other basic Scientology books. A dead thetan is a body, being a body - that is spiritual death. Bodies are comprised of ridges. Ridges are demon circuits with their own past lives. They are injected entities that are softened up thetans. A body is comprised of ridges - they're dead thetans that have become MEST - a ridge.
 
Last edited:
You know, Veda, in reading this over Hu666ard was an implanter from the beginning and all along.

This is from 1952:

These areas are standard, preclear to preclear.​
​
That's telling one and all right there that if you hop an e-meter you'll "discover" this:

Each one has, from preclear to preclear, the same personality in the same body position. The RIGHT INSIDE, for instance, answers up to the​
name of “crew chief”.​
 
My take on all this . . .

Apparently, I'd mocked up -- imagined in my mind with great detail -- exactly what was expected.
What was described in the book.

This is the path I had followed with my entrée to Hubbard and his world and worldview.
  • I spent the money on the books.
  • I spent the hours reading them.
  • I wanted to succeed and not fail.
  • I had a goal I wanted to achieve.
  • I didn't want to disappoint myself (or later on my auditor or pcs).
Well, I did mock up -- imagine with great detail -- exactly what was expected, what
was in all the books and tapes.

My imagination became subservient to, a temporary possession of and controlled by Hubbard's mind.
Dominated by his inventions and mental images and ideas with my willing permission, of course.

Hubbard invented a whole detailed world to explore: space opera, Marcab, Arslycus, exteriorization,
ridges, flows, energies, engrams. And we all mocked it up in unison from the stuff we'd read
and heard. Must be true then. We all see, mock up, imagine the same mental artifacts and memories
he writes about. That's how it all works.

The better the native imagination people had, the better they could mock it all up with great reality
for their viewing and experiencing pleasure.

In some ways, it was a fun escape from the all too real urgencies and travails of living "on planet earth." ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
 
My take on all this . . .

Apparently, I'd mocked up -- imagined in my mind with great detail -- exactly what was expected.
What was described in the book.

This is the path I had followed with my entrée to Hubbard and his world and worldview.
  • I spent the money on the books.
  • I spent the hours reading them.
  • I wanted to succeed and not fail.
  • I had a goal I wanted to achieve.
  • I didn't want to disappoint myself (or later on my auditor or pcs).
Well, I did mock up -- imagine with great detail -- exactly what was expected, what
was in all the books and tapes.

My imagination became subservient to, a temporary possession of and controlled by Hubbard's mind.
Dominated by his inventions and mental images and ideas with my willing permission, of course.

Hubbard invented a whole detailed world to explore: space opera, Marcab, Arslycus, exteriorization,
ridges, flows, energies, engrams. And we all mocked it up in unison from the stuff we'd read
and heard. Must be true then. We all see, mock up, imagine the same mental artifacts and memories
he writes about. That's how it all works.

The better the native imagination people had, the better they could mock it all up with great reality
for their viewing and experiencing pleasure.

In some ways, it was a fun escape from the all too real urgencies and travails of living "on planet earth." ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Yes. There's definitely this.

We used to talk back and forth amongst those I could trust to try to find out if all this stuff was the results of suggestion. One auditor I knew actually experimented and picked up a PC and did the lower grades without telling the PC anything or having them read anything or listen to lectures or mention Scientology at all. The PC EP'd exactly "Standard" for each Grade and process, etc. Per the auditor.

Another auditor was doing M-1 or something that was completely unrelated to an "unhatted" PC who hadn't done any study or training and ran an incident that was identical to one Hubbard described. We reviewed the material and the folder. That one, for sure, was NOT suggestion. M-1 didn't have anything "suggestive" for the incident covered. I can't remember the details but it was stuff like this that "glued" me to the subject even through doubts.

Then, I used to be stationed right by the Purif. So the Purif would go into use and then be dormant for months. People who weren't Scientologists often came for the Purif. Also, Narconon public from time to time, etc. Often times there was only one person there - I don't know if that violates twinning or not - who knows? The point is is that there was no overlap of these people meeting one another to share "wins" or stories or manifestations.

Anyway, I saw a ton of physical manifestations and to keep it generic I just stick to sunburns but trust me, there were a ton of other one-offs that I'm not willing to discuss here that absolutely convinced me that something is taking place here. Also, this was in virtually every single occupant which, to me, rules out the possibility of positive suggestion.

At first, and we'll just stick to sunburns, it was remarkable. It was shocking and astonishing and many, many times the PCs wouldn't even be aware of the manifestation. That is to say that they would be flushing or in a flush and step out to use the can or cool off and have a big old sunburn pattern clear as day on their back and not even know it. I would point it out and they would observe it in the mirror or with a twin and it would be some garment that they wore 30 or 40 years before.

This became so routine that after a while it was unremarkable and to the point that I discontinued even mentioning it to the PCs. They would be having the manifestations and not even know it. They probably never even knew that it happened to this day.

However, I don't remember if this was mentioned in Clear Body, Clear Mind or not or if it was was it a major point that was stressed or what. All I know is that it was almost 1 for 1 and there was always some physical manifestation like PCP as glitter on the body or dye being run out or cigarette burns - all sorts of crap that was physical...pupils dilated from psilocybin - all sorts of stuff. This couldn't be all chalked up to mental suggestion because many of these people weren't into Hubbard or Scientologists. They weren't koolaid drinkers. Also, there's mental suggestion but to then say that everyone would experience it to the degree of a physical reaction is unrealistic, IMHO.

The conclusion that I come up with is that there's something there that's happening beyond someone being spoon fed how they should respond by Hubbard and then having that response.
 
Last edited:
You know, Veda, in reading this over Hu666ard was an implanter from the beginning and all along.

This is from 1952:

These areas are standard, preclear to preclear.​
​
That's telling one and all right there that if you hop an e-meter you'll "discover" this:

Each one has, from preclear to preclear, the same personality in the same body position. The RIGHT INSIDE, for instance, answers up to the​
name of “crew chief”.​

Looking at it chronologically, Hubbard first implanted himself with his Affirmations consisting of recorded spoken statements played back to himself while he was asleep or drugged. According to his confidante and editor, and editor of Ability magazine, John Sanborn, Pain-Drug-Hypnosis was originally pain drugs (such as barbiturates) plus hypnosis.

With his Affirmations, Hubbard "PDHed" himself in 1946 and 1947 and, according to Ron Jr., (with earlier affirmations) as early as the late 1930s. When Dianetics came into being, and Hubbard presented himself as an opponent of hypnosis, and the focus was on erasing painful incidents or engrams, PDH came to mean Pain plus Drugs plus Hypnosis.

The emphasis on words in 1949/1950 Dianetics is a hold over from the importance of spoken words in Hubbard's own implanting of himself with his Affirmations just two or three years earlier.

In 1950 DMSMH, Hubbard, of course, told people the type of content they would find in their reactive minds: Attempted Abortions, beatings, fights, etc.

Then, in 1952, came What to Audit, Whole Track maps, etc.

But there was a period during the mid/latter 1950s when Hubbard liked to say that he was only interested in having people LOOK, and not interested in telling them what they will see.

This was - as earlier mentioned - "letting the reins loose."

It's a trick used by con men.

Even today, one can find Scientologists who will start lecturing about how Hubbard was anti authoritarian and how Hubbard wanted people to think for themselves, etc.


Back of the 1970 first edition Scientology 0 - 8 the Book of Basics
s-l640.jpg


"The simplicity of observation, the simplicity of communication itself and only itself, is functional and will take Man from the bottom to the top. And the only thing I am trying to teach you is to look."
​
This was the last book "done" by John Sanborn. The quote on the back was one liked by Sanborn and was placed there by him.

Two years earlier Sanborn had "done" (compiled and edited) the book, The Phoenix Lectures.


s-l640.jpg

​
Sanborn was one of the good natured, creative, and imaginative people, behind the scenes.

As mentioned, he tried unsuccessfully to have Hubbard remove the Draconian and crazed content from Science of Survival, and was with Hubbard - they sometimes drank and socialized together - when the idea of writing the Hymn of Asia was hatched, first as a prank, then as a PR action forwarding Hubbard's "religion angle" and his desire for respectability, although it was so outrageous, it wasn't published until twenty years later.

During the same year, 1955, Hubbard dictated, into a tape recorder, the contents of the "Russian textbook" on Psycho-politics. Sanborn was there then too. This was a propgnda action to smear dissenters and critics and, of course, psychologists and psychiatrists as communists or communist sympathizers.

Thirty years later, Sanborn recommended plumbing through the strange little "Russian" manual for insight into what Hubbard was really doing. In his own way, Sanborn was making amends for what he had thought was an innovative force for good, which turned out to be something very different.

There were people around Hubbard who thought that Hubbard had something to contribute and, for them, for a while, Hubbard was the center of gravity.

One by one, each of these people was denounced, officially erased, and most were Declared Suppressive Persons.











​
 
First of all, there's plenty of material about multiple bodies, bodies in pawn, etc. Then there's plenty of material about thetan's snipping facsimiles similar to grabbing trading cards, etc. There's plenty of material yacking about doing the same with bodies - snatching, blanketing, snipping - I can't remember all of it. Then there's material that says taking on a body doesn't have to correspond with birth/death or any set interval which ties into what I just wrote before this. Doing a bunk, etc.

i'm generally aware that LRH continued to elaborate his theories to explain away the various problems, dilemmas, etc.

fundamentally i think failed to step back and consider a simpler model like collective memory, and perhaps collective subconscious/consciousness as well. he stuck with an egocentric model being a narcissist, and selling something based on appeal to the egos of customers/recruits, so he turned what was supposed to be simple to begin with into a whole Rube Goldberg construct.
 
We used to talk back and forth amongst those I could trust to try to find out if all this stuff was the results of suggestion. One auditor I knew actually experimented and picked up a PC and did the lower grades without telling the PC anything or having them read anything or listen to lectures or mention Scientology at all. The PC EP'd exactly "Standard" for each Grade and process, etc. Per the auditor.

Another auditor was doing M-1 or something that was completely unrelated to an "unhatted" PC who hadn't done any study or training and ran an incident that was identical to one Hubbard described. We reviewed the material and the folder. That one, for sure, was NOT suggestion. M-1 didn't have anything "suggestive" for the incident covered. I can't remember the details but it was stuff like this that "glued" me to the subject even through doubts.

suggestion can be a very subtle mechanism. questions asked can be unintentionally leading. that's how well meaning therapists ended up inducing kids into having false memories of satanic ritual abuse. partly because you were so immersed in the environment, there could have been things about the constructs that were directive towards producing results aligned with scientology theory, that you and others just didn't recognize as such.

here's another thing to consider, something that i suspect you'll agree is pretty obvious if you really start to think through the implications of LRH's theories, and that i think he sidestepped because it was inconvenient to those theories and to building up an organization the way he wanted to, is psychic powers. if we can have power over MEST, inhabit or take over over bodies, then wouldn't it follow that we would likely have the ability to project our thoughts into or even control, others' minds? then it's entirely possible, if not almost a necessary conclusion, that that the auditor could psychically suggest and lead the subject/PC. the setup of auditing with its isolation and intense internal focus is exactly the sort of environment where you would expect subtle psychic or related phenomenon to manifest, if they exist.
 
i'm generally aware that LRH continued to elaborate his theories to explain away the various problems, dilemmas, etc.

fundamentally i think failed to step back and consider a simpler model like collective memory, and perhaps collective subconscious/consciousness as well. he stuck with an egocentric model being a narcissist, and selling something based on appeal to the egos of customers/recruits, so he turned what was supposed to be simple to begin with into a whole Rube Goldberg construct.


I don't understand this comment:

i'm generally aware that LRH continued to elaborate his theories to explain away the various problems, dilemmas, etc.

What were the various problems, dilemmas, etc.? What were the elaborations?

Or this:

fundamentally i think failed to step back and consider a simpler model like collective memory, and perhaps collective subconscious/consciousness as well. he stuck with an egocentric model being a narcissist, and selling something based on appeal to the egos of customers/recruits, so he turned what was supposed to be simple to begin with into a whole Rube Goldberg construct.

What's the simpler model?
 
Last edited:
suggestion can be a very subtle mechanism. questions asked can be unintentionally leading. that's how well meaning therapists ended up inducing kids into having false memories of satanic ritual abuse. partly because you were so immersed in the environment, there could have been things about the constructs that were directive towards producing results aligned with scientology theory, that you and others just didn't recognize as such.

here's another thing to consider, something that i suspect you'll agree is pretty obvious if you really start to think through the implications of LRH's theories, and that i think he sidestepped because it was inconvenient to those theories and to building up an organization the way he wanted to, is psychic powers. if we can have power over MEST, inhabit or take over over bodies, then wouldn't it follow that we would likely have the ability to project our thoughts into or even control, others' minds? then it's entirely possible, if not almost a necessary conclusion, that that the auditor could psychically suggest and lead the subject/PC. the setup of auditing with its isolation and intense internal focus is exactly the sort of environment where you would expect subtle psychic or related phenomenon to manifest, if they exist.


IDK about this but the mind is, per Scientology, comprised of pictures. Taking control of it doesn't imply influence on someone...per Scientology. Tons of yap from Hell Wrong and goofies in Scientology about being able to "see" others' "pictures" and "incidents" and all sorts of "theta perceptics".

Virtually all auditor training is focused on running the process and not "rabbitting" or letting the PC take the session down another path. This has zero and no pre-determined "answer" or anything. Some...but very few...processes and auditing procedures have an intended realization or "cog" from the PC that is specific - like the Clear cog. These EPs are a High Crime if fed or exposed to the PC. Most of it is meter manifestations and VGIs (very good indicators) in the PC. What this means is a process is run to a cognition and that could be anything. There's no "past life" necessary or anything.

I really don't know how anyone can lead a subject when there's no pre-determined place of arrival. This changes when there's SOLO auditing.

It's different in Dianetics, too, when the auditor is looking for Basic-Basic and "everyone" is genned in on pre-natals and AAs and stuff like that (I can see this being highly suggestive but psychically I don't see that happening) but this style and type of auditing doesn't happen at all. When I first got involved I fully expected to find auditors with notebooks full of bouncers and deniers and yadda...yadda...yadda... and what I found is that NOBODY in the place even knew what the hell those things were.

We're getting in the weeds here. To suggest psychic powers is to suggest that any of this works and that's for certain not happening.

Truer to the thread is that Hubbard wrote stuff and said stuff that people were going to experience in auditing and then they went and experienced it. How much of that is the result of reading and hearing this stuff?

A good experiment would be to take someone with zero exposure and then run Scientology stuff on them without doing much, if any, PC hatting and finding out what happens.

Asking for earlier similars is highly suggestive but it's also possibly the only way to find a real thing if it's there. Asking for earlier similars reminds me of these cop interviews where they get false confessions and it happens quite frequently, apparently. If you keep pressing for an answer the person comes up with something.

THAT THAT THAT THAT

Fishing on a meter.
 
Last edited:
What were the various problems, dilemmas, etc.?

first, that regression and hypnosis therapies tend to produce imagined experience of past lives that are largely if not entirely false, if examined rigorously.

second, that up on even superficial examination, it turns out that multiple people claim to have been the same famous and archetypal characters of their cultural history -- Jesus, Anthony and Cleopatra, Napoleon and Josephine, and so on, in the West -- and which often also overlap in time (say, Queen Victoria and Hitler -- we generally think of them as different eras, but the first died in 1901 and the other was born in 1899). not to mention numerous other issues, like not being able to remember real specifics such as bank account numbers and the locations of buried treasure, or even how to properly speak and read an old language.

What's the simpler model?

a collective memory model like the Akashic Record, in which we all have access to the memories of all of those who have gone before us. that would explain any authentic cases of people who connected to past lives which overlapped in either personage or time, for example.

HTH
 
first, that regression and hypnosis therapies tend to produce imagined experience of past lives that are largely if not entirely false, if examined rigorously.

second, that up on even superficial examination, it turns out that multiple people claim to have been the same famous and archetypal characters of their cultural history -- Jesus, Anthony and Cleopatra, Napoleon and Josephine, and so on, in the West -- and which often also overlap in time (say, Queen Victoria and Hitler -- we generally think of them as different eras, but the first died in 1901 and the other was born in 1899). not to mention numerous other issues, like not being able to remember real specifics such as bank account numbers and the locations of buried treasure, or even how to properly speak and read an old language.



a collective memory model like the Akashic Record, in which we all have access to the memories of all of those who have gone before us. that would explain any authentic cases of people who connected to past lives which overlapped in either personage or time, for example.

HTH


So let me get this straight. Hubbard came up against a problem and experienced a dilemma how?
 
I really don't know how anyone can lead a subject when there's no pre-determined place of arrival.

leading can be pretty subtle. just having the auditor direct the subject to 'go back' or 'find an earlier, similar' is imposing on them the assumption of LRH's theory that the mind is like a computer which records everything, and that there are earlier memories which should be produced. at a certain point when the subject in a suggestive ('reverie') or hypnotic state can no longer produce actual material of any actual possible validity, they may follow the command by producing it from their imagination.

a more obvious example is the classic question 'when did you stop beating your wife?'. the hidden assumption in that is of course easy to see.
 
leading can be pretty subtle. just having the auditor direct the subject to 'go back' or 'find an earlier, similar' is imposing on them the assumption of LRH's theory that the mind is like a computer which records everything, and that there are earlier memories which should be produced. at a certain point when the subject in a suggestive ('reverie') or hypnotic state can no longer produce actual material of any actual possible validity, they may follow the command by producing it from their imagination.

a more obvious example is the classic question 'when did you stop beating your wife?'. the hidden assumption in that is of course easy to see.


Did you read this:

Asking for earlier similars is highly suggestive but it's also possibly the only way to find a real thing if it's there. Asking for earlier similars reminds me of these cop interviews where they get false confessions and it happens quite frequently, apparently. If you keep pressing for an answer the person comes up with something.

THAT THAT THAT THAT

Fishing on a meter.
 
So let me get this straight. Hubbard came up against a problem and experienced a dilemma how?

i think the basic problem is that subjects undergoing auditing started coming up with past life imaginings that he recognized were principally '(1) those which are dub-in and which occur only in cases which dub in in the present life; (2) fantasies built upon reading and imagination, but without somatics'. so he knew his processes were producing a lot of spurious results -- and that he was eliciting if not even implanting false memories.

i'd say that one of his dilemmas was how to address that, without considering or admitting that his whole theory and approach might be fundamentally flawed.

and i think he also had a dilemma of not being able consider a model like the Akashic Record that might better explain things (following scientific method), which given his background in the occult he was almost certainly familiar with, because it would have clashed with the ego-centric approach he had bought in to and was selling.
 
Did you read this:

Asking for earlier similars is highly suggestive but it's also possibly the only way to find a real thing if it's there. Asking for earlier similars reminds me of these cop interviews where they get false confessions and it happens quite frequently, apparently. If you keep pressing for an answer the person comes up with something.

THAT THAT THAT THAT

Fishing on a meter.

yes, ^THAT^ 🙂

though i would argue that as with police interrogations, there are better methods that get at more of the truth by at least eliminating the phenomenon false confessions (and false memories).
 
i think the basic problem is that subjects undergoing auditing started coming up with past life imaginings that he recognized were principally '(1) those which are dub-in and which occur only in cases which dub in in the present life; (2) fantasies built upon reading and imagination, but without somatics'. so he knew his processes were producing a lot of spurious results -- and that he was eliciting if not even implanting false memories.

i'd say that one of his dilemmas was how to address that, without considering or admitting that his whole theory and approach might be fundamentally flawed.

and i think he also had a dilemma of not being able consider a model like the Akashic Record that might better explain things (following scientific method), which given his background in the occult he was almost certainly familiar with, because it would have clashed with the ego-centric approach he had bought in to and was selling.

Have you ever read Dianetics?
 
i think the basic problem is that subjects undergoing auditing started coming up with past life imaginings that he recognized were principally '(1) those which are dub-in and which occur only in cases which dub in in the present life; (2) fantasies built upon reading and imagination, but without somatics'. so he knew his processes were producing a lot of spurious results -- and that he was eliciting if not even implanting false memories.


So how did he "solve" this basic problem?
 
So how did he "solve" this basic problem?

by continually adding tortuous complexity -- without ever actually producing the promised result, or better results, but the way. as you put it:

'material about multiple bodies, bodies in pawn, etc. Then there's plenty of material about thetan's snipping facsimiles similar to grabbing trading cards, etc. There's plenty of material yacking about doing the same with bodies - snatching, blanketing, snipping - I can't remember all of it. Then there's material that says taking on a body doesn't have to correspond with birth/death or any set interval which ties into what I just wrote before this. Doing a bunk, etc. '
 
Back
Top