Hubbard became an "implanter" in September 1963.

Veda

Well-known member
Before that Scientology was a mixed bag, but after that it became an assembly line, making square ball bearings into round ball bearings.


0120-Kinsley-superJumbo.jpg
 
i'd argue he became one whenever exactly it was that he began promoting past life regression through auditing, which is in virtually all if not all cases just a form of induced false memory syndrome -- the functional equivalent of implanting, particularly when the false memories are guided through an atmosphere of suggestion (the telling of his own tales of supposed space opera past lives, subtly setting up the expectation among followers to have similar imaginings while in 'reverie') tending towards those which tend to involve guilt (mass slaughter of planets, etc.), guilt which then leaves the target/victim susceptible to manipulation like a Manchurian Candidate.

just when in the 50s was that point?
 
just when in the 50s was that point?
Post-affirmations . . .
Post-bigamous marriage to Sara, child Alexis, and a loud contentious divorce . . .
Post-bankruptcy of the first Dianetic Foundation . . .
Ron gets bailed out by Purcell and flees to Wichita . . .

From Barbara Kaye, his then lover -- re: Wichita mid-1951 -- states he was pretty bad off:

"I was shocked by his appearance in Wichita. He had visibly deteriorated, both physically and emotionally. He was extremely unkempt, he lived like a street person. He was extremely depressed, talked in a monotone, always on the verge of tears.​
. . .​
"When he went off with Alexis he came by the mansion at Hoover. I was there working and he was in a depression. I could see the way he walked - his head down, dragging his feet."​

However, by some miracle of research, or vivid imagination, he'd figured out the secrets of the universe during the next year and . .

By December 1952, he had traveled to or seen many other universes (PDC Lecture 6):

"I know of three frames positively outside this universe. There’s a universe outside this universe and there’s a universe outside that and its set of universes, and there’s a universe outside that universe. And I know the one beyond that. And it’s not necess... they’re not necessarily getting thinner or more unsubstantial but they don’t run according to the same laws. E equals MC squared won’t work in ‘em. That is not a native characteristic of energy. It just happens to be."​

Among some of Hubbard's early claims:
  • traveling to five other universes outside the mest universe and experiencing said universes with full reality ('52 PDCs)
  • looking over the shoulders in real time of communicators running the implant stations that monitor earth ('52)
  • visiting the main implant station on Venus for an extended time (mid 60's SHSBC)
  • being able to see the history of any earth locale he was visiting by looking at its time track there and then ('52 PDCs)
  • he had full exterior perception ('51-53 and '68 Class VIII course specifically)
  • full memory of his personal history and time track for the last 80 trillion years down to what he did every day -- but maybe not what he ate for breakfast though (mid 60's SHSBC)
  • was running several bodies in and around the mest (material) universe ('52)
I could write a thick book about all the "godly" claims that Hubbard made, especially in his early years.
claims_book450-jpg.12011
 
Post-affirmations . . .
Post-bigamous marriage to Sara, child Alexis, and a loud contentious divorce . . .
Post-bankruptcy of the first Dianetic Foundation . . .
Ron gets bailed out by Purcell and flees to Wichita . . .

From Barbara Kaye, his then lover -- re: Wichita mid-1951 -- states he was pretty bad off:

thanks. and Barbara is a great source, isn't she? an insightful womxn who went on to dedicate herself to getting properly educated and trained, and had a respectable or even notable career as a psychological professional.

as far as dating, i remembered that in the mid 50s LRH claimed credit for sparking interest in past lives that resulted in the Bridey Murphy case -- which was then, a couple of years later, completely and conclusively debunked as being the result of her fabricating below conscious memories while in a hypnotic state, including those of an Irish womxn named Bridie Murphy Corkell who it was discovered had lived across the street from her when she was very young, in a phenomenon technically known as cryptomnesia:


i'm still not sure exactly when in the years before that he first really latched on to past lives. they're a known spurious phenomenon produced by regression techniques of the sort used in auditing (like the 'go back' type commands), so my guess is that people started to have and tell about them, and he realized that he would have to claim them as valid lest the legitimacy of other results of his techniques be called into question. ultimately it evolved that they could be turned into part of a deviously effective control technique as well, though i'm never sure how much such things were planned or even conscious, rather than just being the sort of mechanisms that arise organically in the process of establishing and maintaining a high control group.
 
i'd argue he became one whenever exactly it was that he began promoting past life regression through auditing, which is in virtually all if not all cases just a form of induced false memory syndrome -- the functional equivalent of implanting, particularly when the false memories are guided through an atmosphere of suggestion (the telling of his own tales of supposed space opera past lives, subtly setting up the expectation among followers to have similar imaginings while in 'reverie') tending towards those which tend to involve guilt (mass slaughter of planets, etc.), guilt which then leaves the target/victim susceptible to manipulation like a Manchurian Candidate.

just when in the 50s was that point?

It's a matter of degrees.

The phone book is full of therapists and psychologists who do Past Life Regression. So, by itself, that's another matter.

Anyway... :carryon:

The date September 1963 is being used as that's the time that Hubbard announced that, basically, everything messing a person up was an implant by an implanter (essentially, an ancient extraterrestrial psychiatrist). Before that, Hubbard had spent several years encouraging Scientologists to unravel psychological knots - that had occurred over a long period of time - known as (actual) Goals, Problems, Mass. This was lengthy and complicated and slow.

mm-image.jpg

Scientologists were being asked to LOOK into their own minds.

Then, after collecting a lot of information on what people considered important and were troubled with, Hubbard made a SWITCH: He went from ASKING people to LOOK, to authoritatively TELLING them what they will see when they look. He made what he was TELLING them CONFIDENTIAL and explained that it was DANGEROUS and yet vital to SURVIVAL and well being.

Violating the spirit of his own Auditors Code, Hubbard became the implanter.

(This was now some serious head-gaming.)

The material he put out still "rang bells" for people, because it was derived from the material they had given to him over a period of years.

But, the direction of flow was different. It was now INWARD towards the person from RON, and all confirmed by the e-meter, which was used as a truth detector.

This was a shift, and, along with Keeping Scientology Working of 1965, resulted in an early exodus from Scientology.

(So those familair with Scientology won't be confused, the term GPM is still used in Scientology, but to mean implant GPM (Goal, Problem, Mass), which is a simulated GPM and a kind of engram. Actual GPMs, taking a long time to form, contained thousands of engrams and chains of engrams, like sugar dots on old fashioned candy strips. Thus, the idea went, an actual GPM was far more powerful in messing up a person than an engram or even an engram chain.

09ec4337d7a05f4a6efbf45ab02e78eb.jpg

Before your eyes glaze over completely (and I'm getting a little dizzy myself :scratch:) the point is that there was a SHIFT, from ASKING to TELLING, and it never changed back after that. (And yes, Scientology does some asking, but TELLING is primary.)

Hubbard, for several years, had collected information on people's actual feelings, and to do that, he needed to relax things a little bit.

It's useful in understanding the mirror maze of Scientology, to spot patterns.

The below pattern in blue may have some relevance:

From a 1985 interview of Martin Samuels, Mission Holder who also started the Delphian School in Oregon:

_________________________Begin quote_________________________​


Hubbard operated according to a couple of key patterns...

The first pattern involved basically decent well intentioned people... no one was able to rise in the organization to a point of any real proximity to him, without being attacked and vilified...

The next pattern: It's reap and rape. Hubbard would let the reins loose. He'd let people believe they really could get on with it... He's let people believe they really could prosper to the full extent of their own ability, and enjoy the fruits of their labor.

And, with that kind of freedom, prosperity does occur; inevitably, though, he'd come along and rape and pillage and rip off and take what had been produced. The most dramatic example of this was '82, '83, when he "raped" his most decent people in management along with the mission holders, and looted the entire mission network.


And look at this pattern... He surrounded himself with absolute hooligans as "managers"; guys who beat the shit out of people. This man, who "is this OT, author of Science of Survival, completely able to predict human behavior," surrounded himself with ruthless people - like Miscavige - who got there because they emulated Hubbard's savagery. They emulated his total willingness to completely break, use, and discard another person.

And then after their hands were so bloody - and the only reason their hands were bloody was that they were doing what Hubbard wanted - when it finally started to get to the point where it couldn't be tolerated by people anymore, Hubbard wiped them out. Then he said, "My God! I didn't know!" Scapegoat. He even did that to his own wife, who went to jail in his place...



_____________________________________End quote_____________________________________​


Hubbard let the reins loose during a period in the 1950s and early 1960s.

He wanted people to contribute ideas, techniques, information, and to build.

Then he did a switch.

Patterns.

And, of course, patterns repeat.

In 1950, Hubbard had told people their problems stemmed from engrams, and that the heart of these engrams was to be found in the prenatal engram bank, with ample descriptions of prenatal engrams provided in Dianetics, the Modern Science of Mental Health. Engrams, it seems, largely consisted of Attempted Abortions and wife beatings. (If accounts by others, including a letter from Hubbard's first wife to his second wife are to be believed, Hubbard has remembering and recounting his own experiences as a do-it-yourself abortionist and wife beater.)

Then Hubbard lost the rights to Dianetics in bankruptcy court (long story), and invented Scientology.

Almost immediately, he began telling the newly minted Scientologists the their problems stemmed from incidents on the "whole track" (past lives) and proceeded to tell then what those incidents were.

Mary Sue in 1952 reading What to Audit, later re-titled History of Man.
msh_what-to-audit.jpg

"This is a cold blooded and factual account of your last sixty trillion years."
Mmmm... I think I'll marry this man.​

Around that time - 1951 and 1952 - Hubbard was testing many things that he would formally incorporate - in a very serious way - into Scientology.

In the 1951 book Science of Survival he introduced ideas that, many year later, would become the Suppressive Person doctrine, SP Declares, Disconnection, and Fair Game.

He observed the emotional reactions created by projecting an e-meter dial and its moving needle onto a wall before an audience.

v01no02p14i03.png

​
And, of course, with the book What to Audit, and numerous lectures of the period, he told people the contents of their own minds. Their "whole track," as he explained, was the source of their difficulties.
​
Then he went on to other things.

It wasn't until the mid 1960s that Hubbard placed into full, formal, utilization his complete bag of techniques, and tricks, that he had tested many years earlier.

The time of the (roughly) mid 1960s, when the template for Scientology as it now exists, was established, is, mainly, the subject of this thread.


166eott-jpg.54313






​
 
It's a matter of degrees.

i could see that. maybe say that he went from an accidental or incidental implanter, to a deliberate one who knew what he was doing.

The phone book is full of therapists and psychologists who do Past Life Regression. So, by itself, that's another matter.

i don't think that's so much the case anymore, in part because the techniques involved were so thoroughly debunked and discredited in the 'satanic panic' era where the same sort of faulty, subtly suggestive techniques were used to supposedly 'recover' children's memories of satanic ritual abuse in daycare. at that point some very good research was done which demonstrated just how easy it is to elicit false memories that subjects weave rather elaborately through a process related to dreaming. and from then up until the present there has been further work into the malleability of memory, including demonstrating how easily false memory syndrome is induced, such as experiments in which subjects are lead to create memories of a balloon ride or wedding party accident that never happened --and that such false memories are often actually more vivid seeming than real memories of past events.

i think that's important to recognize because scientology so deviously exploits the phenomenon as a tool of thought reform and control very similar to brainwashing. which isn't to say absolutely that there's no such thing as past lives or memories thereof, just that all or virtually all of what's produced through LRH's techniques is false and manipulative.





​
 
Before that Scientology was a mixed bag, but after that it became an assembly line, making square ball bearings into round ball bearings.


0120-Kinsley-superJumbo.jpg
Hubbard was a implanter before Scientology. His first book Dianetics the modern science of mental health was an implant that one had locks, secondaries and engrams and once "cleared" thru auditing, why one becomes a "clear".

It's all a mental construct by Hubbard and thru his rhetoric, he persuadded a lot of people, myself included.

Of course, it was just rhetoric, but his rhetoric never produced a clear or OT or somebody returning from past life with full recall. I wish it was true, but it ain't.
 
Last edited:
i could see that. maybe say that he went from an accidental or incidental implanter, to a deliberate one who knew what he was doing.

Hubbard was an amateur, but an experienced hypnotist. He knew what he was doing every step of the way.

During a period of several years during the late 1950s Hubbard downplayed the implanter aspect.

Those who were there when he once again became a full fledged implanter, balked and many left.

i don't think that's so much the case anymore, in part because the techniques involved were so thoroughly debunked and discredited in the 'satanic panic' era where the same sort of faulty, subtly suggestive techniques were used to supposedly 'recover' children's memories of satanic ritual abuse in daycare. at that point some very good research was done which demonstrated just how easy it is to elicit false memories that subjects weave rather elaborately through a process related to dreaming. and from then up until the present there has been further work into the malleability of memory, including demonstrating how easily false memory syndrome is induced, such as experiments in which subjects are lead to create memories of a balloon ride or wedding party accident that never happened --and that such false memories are often actually more vivid seeming than real memories of past

Doing a Google search turns up a large number of past life regression therapists, even today.

i think that's important to recognize because Scientology so deviously exploits the phenomenon as a tool of thought reform and control very similar to brainwashing.

Which isn't to say absolutely that there's no such thing as past lives or memories thereof, just that all or virtually all of what's produced through LRH's techniques is false and manipulative.

Having inspected hundreds of folders I've concluded that most past life recall using Scientology methods seldom was more than imagination. But there are some interesting exceptions.



​
 
It's a matter of degrees.

The phone book is full of therapists and psychologists who do Past Life Regression. So, by itself, that's another matter.

Anyway... :carryon:

The date September 1963 is being used as that's the time that Hubbard announced that, basically, everything messing a person up was an implant by an implanter (essentially, an ancient extraterrestrial psychiatrist). Before that, Hubbard had spent several years encouraging Scientologists to unravel psychological knots - that had occurred over a long period of time - known as (actual) Goals, Problems, Mass. This was lengthy and complicated and slow.

mm-image.jpg

Scientologists were being asked to LOOK into their own minds.

Then, after collecting a lot of information on what people considered important and were troubled with, Hubbard made a SWITCH: He went from ASKING people to LOOK, to authoritatively TELLING them what they will see when they look. He made what he was TELLING them CONFIDENTIAL and explained that it was DANGEROUS and yet vital to SURVIVAL and well being.

Violating the spirit of his own Auditors Code, Hubbard became the implanter.

(This was now some serious head-gaming.)

The material he put out still "rang bells" for people, because it was derived from the material they had given to him over a period of years.

But, the direction of flow was different. It was now INWARD towards the person from RON, and all confirmed by the e-meter, which was used as a truth detector.

This was a shift, and, along with Keeping Scientology Working of 1965, resulted in an early exodus from Scientology.

(So those familair with Scientology won't be confused, the term GPM is still used in Scientology, but to mean implant GPM (Goal, Problem, Mass), which is a simulated GPM and a kind of engram. Actual GPMs, taking a long time to form, contained thousands of engrams and chains of engrams, like sugar dots on old fashioned candy strips. Thus, the idea went, an actual GPM was far more powerful in messing up a person than an engram or even an engram chain.

09ec4337d7a05f4a6efbf45ab02e78eb.jpg

Before your eyes glaze over completely (and I'm getting a little dizzy myself :scratch:) the point is that there was a SHIFT, from ASKING to TELLING, and it never changed back after that. (And yes, Scientology does some asking, but TELLING is primary.)

Hubbard, for several years, had collected information on people's actual feelings, and to do that, he needed to relax things a little bit.

It's useful in understanding the mirror maze of Scientology, to spot patterns.

The below pattern in blue may have some relevance:

From a 1985 interview of Martin Samuels, Mission Holder who also started the Delphian School in Oregon:

_________________________Begin quote_________________________​


Hubbard operated according to a couple of key patterns...

The first pattern involved basically decent well intentioned people... no one was able to rise in the organization to a point of any real proximity to him, without being attacked and vilified...

The next pattern: It's reap and rape. Hubbard would let the reins loose. He'd let people believe they really could get on with it... He's let people believe they really could prosper to the full extent of their own ability, and enjoy the fruits of their labor.

And, with that kind of freedom, prosperity does occur; inevitably, though, he'd come along and rape and pillage and rip off and take what had been produced. The most dramatic example of this was '82, '83, when he "raped" his most decent people in management along with the mission holders, and looted the entire mission network.


And look at this pattern... He surrounded himself with absolute hooligans as "managers"; guys who beat the shit out of people. This man, who "is this OT, author of Science of Survival, completely able to predict human behavior," surrounded himself with ruthless people - like Miscavige - who got there because they emulated Hubbard's savagery. They emulated his total willingness to completely break, use, and discard another person.

And then after their hands were so bloody - and the only reason their hands were bloody was that they were doing what Hubbard wanted - when it finally started to get to the point where it couldn't be tolerated by people anymore, Hubbard wiped them out. Then he said, "My God! I didn't know!" Scapegoat. He even did that to his own wife, who went to jail in his place...



_____________________________________End quote_____________________________________​


Hubbard let the reins loose during a period in the 1950s and early 1960s.

He wanted people to contribute ideas, techniques, information, and to build.

Then he did a switch.

Patterns.

And, of course, patterns repeat.

In 1950, Hubbard had told people their problems stemmed from engrams, and that the heart of these engrams was to be found in the prenatal engram bank, with ample descriptions of prenatal engrams provided in Dianetics, the Modern Science of Mental Health. Engrams, it seems, largely consisted of Attempted Abortions and wife beatings. (If accounts by others, including a letter from Hubbard's first wife to his second wife are to be believed, Hubbard has remembering and recounting his own experiences as a do-it-yourself abortionist and wife beater.)

Then Hubbard lost the rights to Dianetics in bankruptcy court (long story), and invented Scientology.

Almost immediately, he began telling the newly minted Scientologists the their problems stemmed from incidents on the "whole track" (past lives) and proceeded to tell then what those incidents were.

Mary Sue in 1952 reading What to Audit, later re-titled History of Man.
msh_what-to-audit.jpg

"This is a cold blooded and factual account of your last sixty trillion years."
Mmmm... I think I'll marry this man.​

Around that time - 1951 and 1952 - Hubbard was testing many things that he would formally incorporate - in a very serious way - into Scientology.

In the 1951 book Science of Survival he introduced ideas that, many year later, would become the Suppressive Person doctrine, SP Declares, Disconnection, and Fair Game.

He observed the emotional reactions created by projecting an e-meter dial and its moving needle onto a wall before an audience.

v01no02p14i03.png

​
And, of course, with the book What to Audit, and numerous lectures of the period, he told people the contents of their own minds. Their "whole track," as he explained, was the source of their difficulties.
​
Then he went on to other things.

It wasn't until the mid 1960s that Hubbard placed into full, formal, utilization his complete bag of techniques, and tricks, that he had tested many years earlier.

The time of the (roughly) mid 1960s, when the template for Scientology as it now exists, was established, is, mainly, the subject of this thread.


166eott-jpg.54313






​

Scientology doctrine and belief that is taken very seriously in the cult.
IMPLANTS.
There is no question that Scientology and Hubbard assign almost all case, all baggage, all abberations to IMPLANTS.
The whole of the Clearing Course is running Implants
The whole of OT 2 is running Implants
The whole of OT 3 is running the *R6* Implant.
Who are all these people that IMPLANT ?
Whole track psychiatrists that lived in other planets other galaxies
🙂
🙂
🙂

It always rolls back to psychiatry
In the 1960s, the early students did a lot of work on GOALS PROBLEMS MASS techniques. People had not found their personal goals and were excited and pleased to learn long range goals and came to understand that the Goal was the mission they had to fulfill in life.
Then one day, Hubbard walked into the Saint Hill Special Briefing Course Room and said that goals found were invalid.
ALL CANCELLED.
Because all Goals found, were IMPLANTED goals, not ACTUAL GOALS.
Students caved in.

A true goal found was now said to be a psychiatric IMPLANT !
~~to be continued.
 
In the 1960s, the early students did a lot of work on GOALS PROBLEMS MASS techniques. People had not found their personal goals and were excited and pleased to learn long range goals and came to understand that the Goal was the mission they had to fulfill in life.

that reminds me of something similar i've read about, that in the '90s the KTL and/or LOC courses (which i think may have been copied from a then-thriving LGAT organization whose success scientology probably envied) had people consider what their real goals in life were -- with the fallout that many determined that it wasn't to be devoting all their resources to scientology, or being on staff. they were then cancelled.

if i've got that wrong or anyone has relevant additional insight to share, i'd love to hear.
 
Having inspected hundreds of folders I've concluded that most past life recall using Scientology methods seldom was more than imagination. But there are some interesting exceptions.

that's the key point, the vast majority of it is obviously spurious (though unfortunately all to many people end up believing in it), even if a very few cases at least leave you wondering.

Tony Ortega posted this today, which hints at just how early on supposed past life memories came up in Dianetics -- again, not surprising as they're a not uncommon and even predictable result of sloppy work with regression therapies.

“Nineteen fifty-one, I rolled up my sleeves and started to investigate the Whole Track. Because in late 1950 it had started to raise its ugly and unseemly head. And auditors who would run into it and try to audit it and pcs who dare bring it up, of course, ran into a considerable social ostracism of one character or another. That was not done. The first Foundation board tried to pass a regulation, a board ruling to the effect that nobody would ever look at, believe in or investigate past lives, and so forth. And yet auditors in auditing them kept running into them, you see? So that probably was the basic split-up of the first Foundation. The first Foundation wanted to sit there comfortably and just grind on and on in present-life engrams and consider that we had it all made and they wanted no further research or investigation of any kind whatsoever. Well, that wouldn’t go and that was that, because auditors were not turning out the results they should have turned out if one had only lived one life. So in 1951 this — I didn’t fly in the teeth of this. I would have investigated anything. I mean, there’s no real resistance on my part. You show me something, tell me I can’t investigate it, I’m liable to investigate it. You show me something and tell me I can investigate it, I’m liable to investigate it. I mean, there is no influence in that line. I, just down through the trillennia, I have not paid attention to and/or paid no attention to people who have told me not to look. I just have not paid any attention to this one way or the other. This, of course, adds up to a total neglect of the ‘finer sensibilities,’ I think they’re called, of other people. The finer sensibilities, I think, is another way of expressing the idea ‘he’s too yellow to look.’” — L. Ron Hubbard, January 25, 1962
Danny Masterson gets boost from Mom & brother Chris, who secure his $3.3 million bail | The Underground Bunker

oh, and one thing i left out before, in one of the interesting experiments in which researchers stimulated false memories of past lives under hypnosis, they then found that in many cases if they asked the subject -- while still 'under' -- what the source of the imaginings was, they were often then able to then cite something like a book or movie from childhood. that's the sort of rigorous 'research or investigation' that LRH obviously didn't do....

also, as for the persistence of regression therapies, other interesting research has shown that they do have some therapeutic value -- even if the memories are completely made up from the start. i liken it to how therapists sometimes work with dolls, things do not have to be real to nonetheless provide a somewhat useful framework to get people to talk about their feelings in ways that can be relieving or even productive.
 
i'd argue he became one whenever exactly it was that he began promoting past life regression through auditing, which is in virtually all if not all cases just a form of induced false memory syndrome -- the functional equivalent of implanting, particularly when the false memories are guided through an atmosphere of suggestion (the telling of his own tales of supposed space opera past lives, subtly setting up the expectation among followers to have similar imaginings while in 'reverie') tending towards those which tend to involve guilt (mass slaughter of planets, etc.), guilt which then leaves the target/victim susceptible to manipulation like a Manchurian Candidate.

just when in the 50s was that point?
I mean he ended up making people believe their own imagination is more than just imagination.

How much of that was "implanting foreign ideas" as opposed to just playing with the preclears own imagination... that would depend on the individual auditor.

I think most auditors end up doing the latter. Did anyone ever independently come up with the invader forces or OTIII incident during their own "wholetrack recall"? I doubt it.

I think Hubbard's lectures and the whole "what to audit?" thing are more of an "implant" than the auditing sessions themselves. That's just my opinion, but keep in mind I was never a high level auditor.
 
I think Hubbard's lectures and the whole "what to audit?" thing are more of an "implant" than the auditing sessions themselves. That's just my opinion, but keep in mind I was never a high level auditor.

i can tell you from what i know of suggestive techniques and hypnosis, that it's the lectures -- delivered in a virtually hypnotic style -- that set up the atmosphere of suggestion, that people will then go into session, have past life imaginings, and that those 'memories' will be of the sort of things 'source' was going on about like space opera lives in the past, and so on.

and yeah, the whole "what to audit?" and other less obvious constructs, set it up so that the supposed guideline not to evaluate for the PC, goes out the window. part of the problem with regression therapies is that given a subject in a suggestible trance state, even asking for an 'earlier, similar' or saying 'go back' is effectively a command which presumes that there are older memories -- and which the subject then starts to fabricate as necessary, in order to comply. come to think of it, you might liken it to false confessions....
 
Last edited:
part of the problem with regression therapies is that given a subject in a suggestible trance state, even asking for an 'earlier, similar' or saying 'go back' is effectively a command which presumes that there are older memories -- and which the subject then starts to fabricate as necessary, in order to comply. come to think of it, you might like it to false confessions....
Entirely agreed here.

I witnessed false confessions during metered interrogations, though almost always these were made because the interrogator created too much fear.
 
. . . even asking for an 'earlier, similar' or saying 'go back' is effectively a command which presumes that there are older memories -- and which the subject then starts to fabricate as necessary, in order to comply. come to think of it, you might liken it to false confessions....
Yes! You're so smart about all this stuff. :yes:

And when you're paying $500-1,000 per hour for auditing, one's "memory" -- or creative imagination
in many situations -- tends to improve quite quickly, as not to linger too, too long on any one thread
of auditing topic or chain of events. The $$$-meter is always clicking away in the background and you
know it.

This one factor is often overlooked in the whole discussion and deconstruction of dianetics and
scientology auditing.

I had a great imagination to begin with and it improved immensely from the auditing and training I got.
(I've written about this ad nauseam on other threads.) Even fooled myself at times. :coolwink:
 
Last edited:
i can tell you from what i know of suggestive techniques and hypnosis, that it's the lectures -- delivered in a virtually hypnotic style -- that set up the atmosphere of suggestion, that people will then go into session, have past life imaginings, and that those 'memories' will be of the sort of things 'source' was going on about like space opera lives in the past, and so on.

and yeah, the whole "what to audit?" and other less obvious constructs, set it up so that the supposed guideline not to evaluate for the PC, goes out the window. part of the problem with regression therapies is that given a subject in a suggestible trance state, even asking for an 'earlier, similar' or saying 'go back' is effectively a command which presumes that there are older memories -- and which the subject then starts to fabricate as necessary, in order to comply. come to think of it, you might like it to false confessions....

The counter argument - that might be made by a past life therapist - is, even if the person is simply imagining, he's still consulting some portion of his subconscious mind. Even if he's remembering a movie scene, why is the movie scene important to him? Is there something else behind it, buried deeeeep in the subconscious?

When Star Wars, the movie, was released, in 1977, it presented a tale from long ago, and excited the Scientologists who were seeing a movie - literally featuring what they knew as "whole track." It was a big "validation" for them.

There really were fedora hats and telephones millions of year ago!​

There were, no doubt, in auditing sessions, lots of Jedi Knights recalling their adventures, and probably a few Galactic Empire Storm Troopers getting their withholds off.

(Hubbard even wrote a film treatment titled Revolt in the Stars, to get into the action, but it flopped.)

The Scientology book, Have you lived before this Life?, used Star wars imagery in it advertisements.

e1usu1qq21641.jpg


Perhaps we should ask some psychologist who does Past Life regression to come in and explain what he does.

There are lots of them on the Internet.

MjAyMC0wNS0yMyAwODoxMzo1Mw==_99419906_10216291066444614_2536180043713871872_o.jpg


Back to Scientology, and Dianetics: It can be hard to change a person's mind who's used an e-meter, and has seen the meter respond, just as his materials stated it would. It can be convincing to someone auditing a "pc" on Dianetics, or on the Lower Grades, or other actions. In confidential instructions for the Solo levels, Hubbard told Scientologists that any doubts (or "unreality") they have, will disappear once they see the meter reactions.

Other things, however, contradict the certainty that the e-meter encourages.

For example, the now out of print book, Dianetics Today, featured a bunch of Dianetic R3R sessions in the back of the book, sessions C/Sed (Case Supervised) by Hubbard on the ship in 1969. To say the least, it was unimpressive, with low tone arm motion (usually not a good thing in metered auditing), and dumb and insignificant "somatics" (pains, aches, sensations, emotions, attitudes, etc.) being addressed. Everyone was going through the motions, and was happy to receive a "well done" from the "Commodore," but it still seemed like a colossal waste of time.

And, over the years, it became obvious that the "somatics" that Dianetics had "handled" had not really been handled at all. They were still there in many instances. Hubbard even issued a bulletin about "OTs" who still had "somatics."
"They need Dianetics!" it blared in big letters.

Some years later, Hubbard announced that it was "deadly" to run (use) Dianetics on Clears or OTs, and released NOTs which was for Clears and OTs, and was supposed to remove their somatics.

By 1980, Hubbard, judging from the OT 8 HCOB, had decided that none of this had worked very well because of meddling from beings outside the physical universe, or something like that. But that missive from Hubbard was made to disappear fast.

It would have been bad for business.

Hubbard, who, from a reliable source, was on happy pills at the time to calm him down, possibly didn't even remember it. (Mary Sue, his wife, was headed to prison for crimes committed under his direction - a tense period.)

The people around Hubbard were always on the alert for gems of wisdom or "tech" that Hubbard might blurt out, to then be presented as a new "tech breakthrough," and marketed.

Two years later, the Pain and Sex Bulletin appeared. But, as with the 1980 OT 8 theory, there was no practical, or "rundown" accompanying it. (Which was probably just as well. :panic:)

As Hubbard faded, all they had was scraps.

Pat_Broeker_Number-e1548209386167.png

​
And every scrap, every utterance, is carefully preserved.


Footnote:

IIRC, "Recall the earliest time you can_________________" was used in the 1951 Self Analysis book for "earlier," then, in 1952, another version of the Self Analysis book appeared where the "recall" questions were replaced with instructions to "mock up," which was called "Creative Processing."

Hubbard explanation of "facsimiles" from late 1952/1953 was that a "thetan" was better off without any facsimiles, but that "thetans," nonetheless, like to collect facsimiles.

It became pretty airy for a while, then, around the time that "withhold pulling" and "Security Checking" became a "thing," (roughly 1960), it became very "solid" and "serious," as they say.

And it's been frozen that way ever since, with the "airy" parts available in some of Hubbard's books and some of his lectures, which serves nicely to cause a person to let his guard down.

For R3R Dianetics the "earlier" question is phrased something like, "Is there an earlier incident____________"

Those who do not before this life, eventually, are to be given the Past Life Remedy, "What attitudes would make one unwilling to go earlier than this life," etc.

As one enters the confidential part of the Grade Chart, the seeming courtesy of asking, is replaced by matter-of-fact telling. All subtlety is gone, after all, it's vitally important to your survival and well being for the next endless trillions of years, and the material was un-confrontable before Hubbard discovered and "mapped" it.
 
And when you're paying $500-1,000 per hour for auditing, one's "memory" -- or creative imagination
in many situations -- tends to improve quite quickly, as not to linger too, too long on any one thread
of auditing topic or chain of events. The $$$-meter is always clicking away in the background and you
know it.

thanks for bringing that up -- in the dysfunctional, manipulative atmosphere of scientology, there's that extra pressure, too.

i happen to have acquired a certain amount of experience with NLP and hypnosis, to have spent some time including a bit first-handing seeing how groups use them, and then had the opportunity to learn from people like keen observers, and experienced people like y'all here. i appreciate the opportunity for dialog.
 
Any way you wish to slice up or examine Hubbard, Dianetics, Scientology, it all will boil down to Hubbards use of rhetoric.
 
thanks for all that info and context.

i didn't know about Past Life Remedy, but that's an interesting piece of the puzzle, and fits to show how LRH became more obviously directive over time. it seems to me that he was always working on the fly to try to fix the problems with his flawed techniques and unfulfilled (and unrealistic) promises, as well as keep control of his organization and following. first he has the problem of some people experiencing past life imaginings that he has to take into account -- including the classic problems well known before he came across them, of those imaginings falsifying themselves by turning out to sometimes overlap in time, and then of course everyone wanting to imagine that they were the same iconic historical figures like Caesar or Cleopatra -- and then he has the problem that not everyone is experiencing them....

The counter argument - that might be made by a past life therapist - is, even if the person is simply imagining, he's still consulting some portion of his subconscious mind. Even if he's remembering a movie scene, why is the movie scene important to him? Is there something else behind it, buried deeeeep in the subconscious?

that's the point i think i acknowledged in an earlier comment, with the reference to therapists' use of dolls. the Rorschach blot test is another classic example of how an element of therapeutic (or analytical) framework doesn't necessarily have to have any internal validity, it can still work effectively as a tool, or target for projection.
 
Back
Top