Aaron posts Jenna Miscavage's recent Vids.

In my view, the closer most Sea Org members worked near David Miscavige, the worse it was for them. I doubt Jenna would have been happy had she traded places with Mike Rinder. He was incarcerated off and on for several years, spending a total of about two years in The Hole.

Here's what ChatGPT had to say about The Hole:

The conditions in The Hole at Scientology’s International Base (near Hemet, CA) have been described in multiple sworn declarations, interviews, and books — including Mike Rinder’s own accounts, those of other Sea Org executives, and media investigations. They were harsh, degrading, and consistent with coercive control and psychological abuse.


Here’s a breakdown:

🔹 Physical Conditions

  • Location: A set of double-wide trailers on the property at Int Base, originally office space, converted into a detention facility.
  • Locked in: Doors and windows secured; members couldn’t freely leave.
  • Sleeping arrangements: Dozens of people crammed into a small space, often sleeping on the floor in sleeping bags or under desks.
  • Hygiene: Limited showers; bathrooms were inadequate for the number of detainees. Poor ventilation, overcrowding, and unsanitary conditions were common.
🔹 Daily Life and Punishments
  • Sleep deprivation: Detainees often forced to stay awake until 2–3 a.m. for “confession” or “confession by committee” sessions, then up again early.
  • Food deprivation: Meals sometimes consisted of rice and beans; at times food was restricted or withheld.
  • Verbal and physical abuse: Accounts describe people being screamed at, slapped, punched, or physically restrained by fellow detainees under orders.
  • Group confessions: Prisoners required to denounce each other in “struggle sessions,” sometimes going on for hours.
  • Menial labor: Scrubbing floors, menial cleaning, or physical drills used as punishment.
🔹 Psychological Control
  • Humiliation rituals: People forced to admit “crimes” (disloyal thoughts, doubts, mistakes) in front of peers.
  • Isolation from family and outside world: Contact with outsiders was cut off; detainees couldn’t see loved ones.
  • Randomness of reprieve: Sometimes people were temporarily let out to handle assignments, but could be sent back arbitrarily, reinforcing a sense of helplessness.
  • Constant surveillance: Guards or loyal staff watched detainees, ensuring no one left without permission.
🔹 Reported Comparisons
  • Rinder himself compared it to a prison camp or psychological gulag.
  • Other ex-members (e.g., Tom DeVocht, John Brousseau, Amy Scobee, Marc Headley) likened it to North Korean re-education tactics — public humiliation, group pressure, and deprivation used to break down will.
  • The FBI investigated The Hole in 2009–2010 on suspicion of human trafficking and unlawful imprisonment (though no charges were filed at the time).
  • 🔹 Duration
Some executives said they were kept for months to years.

  • Mike Rinder: in and out from 2004 to March 2007 (about 2 years accumulated).
  • Others reported up to 7 years of confinement.

✅ Summary: The Hole was not a figurative punishment — it was a locked, degrading, prison-like environment where Sea Org executives were confined, humiliated, and coerced into compliance. Conditions combined physical hardship, deprivation, and intense psychological abuse.

Yes...a saga for sure. But to be honest, I am not really interested in The Hole and what was done to Mike Rinder.

I would be interested in what Mike Rinder did during those 25 years....
 
Rinder Obscura
(Latin "obscūrus" ... dark, dim, unclear, hidden, or little-known)

Q: When you were the main spokesperson, how did you handle press
questions about Ron’s promised return in 20-25 years to resume his work?

Mike Rinder says:
August 22, 2013 at 4:34 pm

I was never asked that question. I guess in some respects I believed that would be the case, though I never saw anything written by him that specifically stated that he would return in a different body, though there were certainly rumors about him having left instructions about how he could be identified. Perhaps they were true.

Do I think he has the capability of returning? Not in those terms. I believe that one lives for more than one life with more than one body. But the fact is, after this long, he has not “returned” as “Ron in a new body.”

And I place great credence in what Sarge said about the later years of his life. There are simply too many other facts that align to the notion that he was NOT in fact in good shape and certainly was not “causatively discarding his body to continue research that would be hindered by a body.”

If this was the case, there would have been a LOT more detailed hat write ups and turnovers and farewell messages — even a film or video. A lot of things I took as “gospel” from the time I was young concerning the infallibility of LRH I no longer see that way. Including this idea that he could knowingly postulate a future body and identity and return with full recall of his last lifetime.

Q: What’s the back story? Why did management cover up LRH’s apparent failure
to deliver on many of his more hyperbolic OT promises . . . and from what I
can tell even achieve them himself? Why lie to all of us from 1986 on? Seems
like there was an enormous conspiracy of silence and a forwarding of a patently
untrue LRH mythology. The lies told were an unthinkable betrayal.

Mike Rinder says:
April 21, 2013 at 9:55 pm

Marty’s books and blog have covered this pretty extensively. There was a hidden data line inside the church too. I was not aware that these materials didnt exist until after I left.

Miscavige wanted them so he would have a carrot to hold out. But he also could NOT afford to say “Sorry folks, I know LRH said OT IX and X were ready and there was a Grade Chart with OT X1 to XV on it, but they don’t exist” as it would have caused a revolt. In order to maintain his position he has had to pretend to be fully in alignment with LRH and the ONE carrying out his wishes and intention. It has been a slow process to convince the masses that he is the new Messiah. And now it is valuable to him to appear to have something that people want but cannot have “yet” …

michaeljrinder on March 10, 2014 at 1:27 pm said:
If you are interested in what happened with the IRS and Miscavige and LRH, read Marty Rathbun’s books. Read his blog. Watch the videos we did together.

I can tell you from my perspective, it gets tired writing and rewriting what happened, only to have people come along and pose these same questions “there is something we don’t know and I sure wish there was a way of finding out.”

Well, you do. You just need to read it. It has been laid out by him (and to a lesser extent me). We were there from the very beginning and at each meeting with the IRS all the way through to exemption. There is no mystery. It has been very well described. So too the ascent of Miscavige and death of LRH.

This long quote boils down to a simple thing — make the truth known. That is what we have been attempting to do for years. You apparently don’t acknowledge anything that Marty has written or said because he is in your eyes a squirrel and you have disconnected from him. But I don’t know where you hope to find the real story…

The only other people present for the IRS were Miscavige, Norman Starkey, Heber Jentzsch and the lawyers Monique Yingling, Jerry Feffer, Tom Spring and Bill Walsh.

The only other people that know more about LRH’s death are Pat and Annie Broeker, Ray Mithoff and Earle Cooley.

This is exactly why we have spent thousands of hours doing blogs, doing media interviews, shooting videos and writing books.

michaeljrinder on March 10, 2014 at 9:00 pm said:
Sarge (Steve Pfauth) is another one who has weighed in, and he was there. On the rise of Miscavige and death of LRH far more intimately than me. And concerning the death of LRH, far more intimately than anyone else left alive on earth (the only two people that knew more than him were LRH and Annie). But it seems his picture does not match what people want to believe so it gets rejected. It’s covered in Marty’s book and on his blog.

michaeljrinder on March 11, 2014 at 1:48 pm said:
Ron absolutely abolished the GO. The Exec Strata was formed and the issues written about it before the formation of OSA. I had personal conversations with LRH about the disbandment of the GO and his desire to see it eradicated entirely as it had become a liability. You do not think that the GO was disbanded without his knowledge and Guardian PL canceled etc etc etc. Where are the docs? They don’t exist, remember, LRH was trying to avoid being connected in any way tot he actions of the GO or Mary Sue, he was an unindicted co-conspirator. Nothing was in writing. And though he had expressed a LOT of disgust about the GO during the “Confront of Evil” period and the formation of the Office of Evaluation and Execution, where it came up routinely that GO staff were employing org staff in their personal business, the reason for disbanding the GO was that they were not protecting him from criminal and civil liability. He considered they had betrayed him (inclusive of Mary Sue).

The idea that he knew nothing about Snow White and the illegal acts that were ongoing is tantamount to saying L. Ron Hubbard was blind, unaware and incapable of spotting an outpoint. That was NOT the case. He was briefed by Mary Sue every single day at lunch during the heyday of the GO Ops — in detail. If she didnt tell him “Joe Blow infiltrated the IRS and got documents” she told him what they knew (if you don’t believe he expected to be briefed about everything the GO was doing, then you also give him less credit than he deserved, he was not one not to be curious) and he would have figured it out. Believe me, the programs and actions written to implement Snow White WERE know and authorized all the way to the top.

LRH directed exactly what was to be done at the Mission Holders Conference in SFO following the one in Clearwater. The whole thing was recorded so it could be sent to him. He listened to it, sent Miscavige and the others commendations and ordered that the entire transcript be published.

All of this information has been broadly published before. Just read Marty Rathbun’s books and blog and numerous other sources.

michaeljrinder on May 17, 2014 at 4:37 pm said:
I wish to comment only on one statement in this write up that I feel is quite misleading and I happened to be directly involved with it at the time.

NOTs was not developed because people were not making it on OT 5 and 6. It was developed because LRH got extremely ill in 1978. He busted Paulette Ausley who was his auditor and called for David Mayo to be brought to La Quinta from Flag to audit him.

During the course of the auditing, LRH complained that it was not improving his condition and concluded that the assist program (that included Dianetics R3R) was wrong. He then outlined for Mayo what to do in session and this was then compiled into NOTs and other issues like Dianetics Forbidden on Clears and OTs. This is the genus of NOTs, not any failures on the part of others on old OT 5 and 6.

LRH did direct RTRC to make NOT’s “OT V” and Solo NOTs “OT VII.”


Just read Marty’s books and blog, I guess
¯\_(ツ)_/¯

marty600-jpg.28085


All very interesting.

At this point....I really don't want to know about this sort of stuff.....regarding the upper OT levels.

Is Rinder talking about this stuff ......Pre Rathbun return to the fold...or Post Rathbun return to the fold....??

I gather from the dates, probably Pre Rathbun.

I would be interested in Rinder talking about what he did.....rather than what someone else wrote or what someone else said to him.

For example.....those 2 Private Eyes.....recently in the Scien News lines.....

But, guess it is too late for that now.

To me it sounds like gaslighting or a canard...... Misdirection. But that is up to the guy asking the questions, I suppose. He wouldn't have been a very good auditor....
 
michaeljrinder on March 11, 2014 at 1:48 pm said:
All of this information has been broadly published before. Just read Marty Rathbun’s books and blog and numerous other sources.
Footnote: Mike Rinder recommended Marty's books many times around 2013-14.
He was an editor on the third book, the best one (and only good one from Marty), IMO:

Edited (and obviously
blessed) by Mike Rinder

61I62zxPpEL._SL1360_.jpg

:coolwink:
 
Last edited:
I didn't mean to make this a thread about Rinder.....

I just don't like the guy.....and there is nothing anyone can say that will change my mind.

I don't like Rathbun either.....

There are aspects of the Spiritual side of Scientology that we never discuss much here.
I have my own thoughts and experiences with that, that I have never expressed here....

And I think these guys and others have not told the truth in any way, shape or form about that either......

Those remain hidden .....
 
Don't worry. This thread is as dead as any thread that was ever begun.
:LOL: :LOL: :LOL: :LOL: :LOL: :LOL: :LOL:

I guess The Hole was pretty bad....

But, sounds like a holiday compared to cleaning out the grease traps at the Complex Kitchen.....or Asbestos removal from the ship....

I guess those Sec Checks can make you sweat.....
 
I guess The Hole was pretty bad....

But, sounds like a holiday compared to cleaning out the grease traps at the Complex Kitchen.....or Asbestos removal from the ship....

I guess those Sec Checks can make you sweat.....
Lee, its quite revealing and even unsettling how as one is drawn deeper into the submissive, compliant abyss of investing oneself into a cult, a person can find themselves doing things they would otherwise abhor (and in my opinion, still do at some deeper suppressed level out of fear of losing the security of their place in that world, which has become everything for them), and even well after leaving, find it hard to fully swallow how hurtful, cold and unkind their attitudes and actions toward others were, just how much they betrayed others and their own sense of right and wrong, and that could take long and dedicated reflection, with or without therapy, including the sense of dread and weakness that they could be so subsumed by another or others. I believe that at least Mike Rinder worked to compensate for having lived so wrong by working earnestly to shine a light on the truth of the cult as recognized through his own experience. How could there not be things he's done that he's not proud of and would rather not visit in detail?
I don't see that you are running some kind of anti- Mike Rinder campaign in what you are sharing, you're only expressing your feelings from what you experienced. How much or how little, if any, Mike ever had to do with what you went through, if anything, is not clear or known, but as an apparent controlling authority, he was part of and represents how you were treated. It reminds me a little bit of how I was "corrected" by someone senior to me in the hierarchy of the NY org for warmly welcoming back a friend who had been "blown" for a little while and told I should have been cold and distant because of their "ethics condition". Fortunately, that mindset didn't resonate with me, but it serves as an example of how the Scientology mindset can warp a person's attitude and behavior- although, I'd also speculate how some people could actually gravitate toward that because being that way does resonate with their insecurities and their need to feel dominant and superior to feel safe. Scientology certainly does invite such attitudes to be embraced to channel their emotional needs to control them to control others to forward Scientology's objectives.
 
Given the post Mike Rinder had when in the Sea Org, he clearly wasn't an angel. But Aaron mischaracterizes certain things about Rinder to worsen them. (He appears to be suffering from RDS (Rinder Derangement Syndrome)

I’ve just watched his video from a few days ago on Mike.

Needless to say ASL just comes across as completely unhinged.

He’s basically clapping back at videos Mike made about 6 weeks before he passed, when he had late stage cancer and probably didn’t have all the mental faculties to be able to accurately recall all the events which he was trying to address.


 
I’ve just watched his video from a few days ago on Mike.

Needless to say ASL just comes across as completely unhinged.

He’s basically clapping back at videos Mike made about 6 weeks before he passed, when he had late stage cancer and probably didn’t have all the mental faculties to be able to accurately recall all the events which he was trying to address.


I find Aaron's nasty unsupported unrelenting attacks on Mike Rinder, even as he was dying of cancer and who never stooped to firing back with such vitriol, beyond tasteless, all the way to pathetically narcissistic in fact. Like David Miscavige, when discreditable facts came out about Aaron's criminally abusive behaviors, rather than having a shred of accountability, or having the common sense to focus on promoting what would at least appear more favorable activities, Aaron draws more attention to his lack of character with his attack postings. This is what made it necessary for the Foundation to cut him loose; he's a total hypocrite, exhibiting the same sort of behaviors as the "Church" of Scientology, while presenting himself as the whistle-blower and truth-teller, and the Aftermath Foundation recognized that they couldn't support his hypocrisy and maintain the credibility to be worthy and effective.
And as in all or most of Aaron's postings, he is heavy on grandiose and dramatic claims and light, if not absolutely vacant, on evidence or proof.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top