The Scientology "Management by Statistics" System

Scientology itself is of course completely flawed, but so is the whole management system of stats/graphs/conditions/etc. It's all built on the idea that stats can and should always be going up and that if they don't go up the person who is responsible for that stat is causing it. Many industries, and whole economies, go through cycles (busy season, slow season) and Scientology management tech makes no allowances for this.

plus industries and types of organizations go through eras of extinction unless they evolve. there will never be an upswing in the cycle or a busy season for scn as it is now, any more than there will be for horse buggy whip makers.

also one thing this and other comments (thanks everyone!) reminds me of is that Hubbard completely missed (and failed to foresee) the total quality management revolution that saved businesses based on the old statistical industrial management system which adapted, and swept away those that didn't.

it also occurs to me that Hubbard didn't even do a good job of tracking the basic relationship between activity and income; i take it for instance orgs don't keep track of how much business comes in based on letters out, and instead take it on faith that 'source's' gut feeling from the 50s and 60s was (and continues to be) right, bolstered by anecdotal examples of occasional successes.
 
.

Were you ever on staff HH at a mission or org?

.

I was personally never in Scientology. Whatever I know about Scientology I gleaned during a 34 year stretch when Mr. Hubbard and the COS was a customer of mine that I used to sell clipboards, graph paper, clay, mimeograph ink and foolscap goldenrod paper to.

After Mr. Hubbard passed away the new management stopped ordering through me and sadly I had to close my business. That's why I became very "antagonistic" and joined this website to vent my bye-past-charges.

In case anyone finds this interesting, here is where I first met Mr. Hubbard when i was a door-to-door office supplies salesman back in 1952. I knocked on his door at 5501 N 44th St, Phoenix, AZ 85018—and the rest is history!

l-ron-hubbard-on-porch-of-house-in-phoenix.jpg

(1952): photo taken moments after Mr. Hubbard placed his first order for graph paper and clipboards


...
​

.
 
Last edited:
I remember understanding how destructive managing by statistics was when I tried to figure out statizising computer programming. "More lines of code" is NOT a good thing. "More lines of comments" is NOT a good thing. What you want is good, effective, maintainable code. That might end up with more lines or far fewer lines. But just pushing for just more lines will ALWAYS create worse code.

that's a great example, particularly when it comes to the modern era of technology where quality (and precision) are key. often less, is more.

This is true of many things. Only pushing for more more more will ALWAYS destroy an organization.

i think there are some things, like basic industries, where it is less true. and there are some types of organizations, like those heavily based on sales, where the negative consequences can take longer to manifest. it seems to me Hubbard benefitted to some extent from leading scn at a point in its life cycle and in the larger trends that it depended on for its success, that allowed him to willfully ignore such realities and get away with it more or less.
 
At one time when I was having to write letters, put out a magazine and other stuff, I got a load of files from CF.

If the files were old with no responses, sometimes I would simply write "Where are you?" and post that.

That got a few letters out in a hurry and I never got any feedback about it either.

I was only Div 2 Sec for about a year or so before I left, So I often wonder how long I would have gotten away with that one.
 
At one time when I was having to write letters, put out a magazine and other stuff, I got a load of files from CF.

If the files were old with no responses, sometimes I would simply write "Where are you?" and post that.

That got a few letters out in a hurry and I never got any feedback about it either.

I was only Div 2 Sec for about a year or so before I left, So I often wonder how long I would have gotten away with that one.
Perhaps you never saw any of the letters that did come in, only to be stamped in reply to these letters ENTHETA, (I have read some very expressive angry and quite honestly rude letters) then the CF would be filed away in HCO. As the backlogged filing would be handled a new file would be made up and that person would get more annoying letters. Now in theory a piece of card should be kept in the place the file originally was, but sometimes there was misfiling, duplicated names, and worse they went missing, especially when the GO decided that as the member of the pubic was threatening legal action all record of the person should be kept by them. I tried to explain all this to a smartly presented GO person who just couldn't get it. Of course every department would have their own card files and address books that they used to call people from. I have to feel sorry for these very irate ex-customers.
 
plus industries and types of organizations go through eras of extinction unless they evolve. there will never be an upswing in the cycle or a busy season for scn as it is now, any more than there will be for horse buggy whip makers.

also one thing this and other comments (thanks everyone!) reminds me of is that Hubbard completely missed (and failed to foresee) the total quality management revolution that saved businesses based on the old statistical industrial management system which adapted, and swept away those that didn't.

it also occurs to me that Hubbard didn't even do a good job of tracking the basic relationship between activity and income; i take it for instance orgs don't keep track of how much business comes in based on letters out, and instead take it on faith that 'source's' gut feeling from the 50s and 60s was (and continues to be) right, bolstered by anecdotal examples of occasional successes.

They track letters in. Anyone with access to the orgs stat system could do some basic digging and see that letters out are a complete waste of time. But because LRH said letters out is the thing to do, that's what they do. They blindly take it on faith because LRH is never wrong. Of course many of the top/best execs and regs know letters are a waste of time and that LRH was wrong about this. When Flag regs are off quota you can bet the people running them don't tell them to go write letters, and they don't give "writing more letters" as how they'll handle their flapping GI quota.

As we've discussed, a lot of Scientology's growth and success comes from luck, they had the right message at the right time. Like you said, LRH never had a good understanding of what caused Scientology's success and coupled with that had a complete inability to adapt, and that's now baked into Scientology. We can be thankful that LRH never grasped marketing or how to attract people beyond some basic gimmicks.

At one time when I was having to write letters, put out a magazine and other stuff, I got a load of files from CF.

If the files were old with no responses, sometimes I would simply write "Where are you?" and post that.

That got a few letters out in a hurry and I never got any feedback about it either.

I was only Div 2 Sec for about a year or so before I left, So I often wonder how long I would have gotten away with that one.

Do you think people write letters differently? Those "where are you" letters are common today, it's way more efficient to pump out 50 of those letters than it is to spend the same amount of time putting out 10 carefully written ones. They all have the same product at the end of the day, nothing.
 
They track letters in. Anyone with access to the orgs stat system could do some basic digging and see that letters out are a complete waste of time.

but there's no specific mechanism for gauging just how much income results from letters out, is there?

my understanding is that even mid-century corporations and sales organizations were able to track things like that, and figure out what was actually productive. i believe that some of the old missions also started to figure out such things, before they got cracked down on for a variety of reasons including too much questioning of standard practices, and attempting innovation....
 
Anyone with access to the orgs stat system could do some basic digging and see that letters out are a complete waste of time.
All of Scientology is a complete waste of time.
 
Last edited:
but there's no specific mechanism for gauging just how much income results from letters out, is there?

my understanding is that even mid-century corporations and sales organizations were able to track things like that, and figure out what was actually productive. i believe that some of the old missions also started to figure out such things, before they got cracked down on for a variety of reasons including too much questioning of standard practices, and attempting innovation....

Correct, that's the part you'd have to do a little digging to figure out, track who responded and then track who paid. They really should have a stat "GI from letters in" or something similar that could track when people mailed in a check or came back on lines due to a letter (and then later paid). But they don't track that, if they did it would sit at zero. Letters out producing GI is literally magical thinking, GI will go down and then they'll show the letters out graph and show there was a dip three weeks ago, so obviously GI crashed this week.
 
They track letters in. Anyone with access to the orgs stat system could do some basic digging and see that letters out are a complete waste of time. But because LRH said letters out is the thing to do, that's what they do. They blindly take it on faith because LRH is never wrong. Of course many of the top/best execs and regs know letters are a waste of time and that LRH was wrong about this. When Flag regs are off quota you can bet the people running them don't tell them to go write letters, and they don't give "writing more letters" as how they'll handle their flapping GI quota.

As we've discussed, a lot of Scientology's growth and success comes from luck, they had the right message at the right time. Like you said, LRH never had a good understanding of what caused Scientology's success and coupled with that had a complete inability to adapt, and that's now baked into Scientology. We can be thankful that LRH never grasped marketing or how to attract people beyond some basic gimmicks.



Do you think people write letters differently? Those "where are you" letters are common today, it's way more efficient to pump out 50 of those letters than it is to spend the same amount of time putting out 10 carefully written ones. They all have the same product at the end of the day, nothing.
Well this was back in the late 70s.
Most of the letters were written with more due consideration, from what I read within the files.
 
.

Letters out producing GI is literally magical thinking, GI will go down and then they'll show the letters out graph and show there was a dip three weeks ago, so obviously GI crashed this week.

.
LOL

That's what happens when rationality is replaced by Orwellian slogans such as: "OUTFLOW EQUALS INFLOW".


SCN EXEC
Congratulations! You just were awarded "Staff Member of the Week!"

LETTER REG
Really? Wow, what did i do to deserve that?

SCN EXEC
Well, this week our org's Gross Income went up enough for the
first time in 29 weeks so we could afford to buy toilet paper.

LETTER REG
I did that? Wait, how did i do that?

SCN EXEC
Well, we did an eval and discovered that 30 weeks ago, instead of
writing an average of 500 letters per week, your letters outflow
stat went up to 505 letters out per week.

LETTER REG
Wow! So are you saying that some of those people that I wrote
letters to actually came in the org and paid money for services?

SCN EXEC
No, but that's not important. Because the income going up doesn't
have to have anything to do with the people that received letters.
Our income went up because our outflow went up. It's like
a universal axiom or some junk that Ron discovered.

LETTER REG
Wow cool!!! Now for the first time of being on staff for 30 years
I finally understand why our org does weird shit that causes 99%
of our public to eventually blow—which has turned our
org into a ghost town. I finally get it! Our ideal org
has been "outflowing" Scientologists!

SCN EXEC
That's right! With all that outflow, it's now just a matter of time before
the com lag flattens and a huge flood of new Scientologists suddenly
shows up at our front doors—literally begging us to take their money!

..
​
 
Last edited:
Correct, that's the part you'd have to do a little digging to figure out, track who responded and then track who paid. They really should have a stat "GI from letters in" or something similar that could track when people mailed in a check or came back on lines due to a letter (and then later paid). But they don't track that, if they did it would sit at zero.

again, from what i hear it's not quite zero. but if they tracked the stat, they'd have seen it decline over the decades and could make a more informed decision about where to put their resources. oh, and they could even go back and analyze the . i think it's just another fairly obvious example of something that was outdated and poorly implemented, even when it was new to scn and touted by Hubbard as the best thing in this sector of the galaxy.

Well this was back in the late 70s.
Most of the letters were written with more due consideration, from what I read within the files.

back then orgs didn't have vast files of people who'd lost interest decades ago. it was probably worth given the fewer and more recent files due consideration, and produced some real results.
 
All of Scientology is a complete wast of time.
All of Scientology is a complete wast of time.

Don't you mean waste, which I agree.
 
but there's no specific mechanism for gauging just how much income results from letters out, is there?

my understanding is that even mid-century corporations and sales organizations were able to track things like that, and figure out what was actually productive. i believe that some of the old missions also started to figure out such things, before they got cracked down on for a variety of reasons including too much questioning of standard practices, and attempting innovation....
what you missing to try to understand is that the book income is separate from Gross income. It's two systems. Book income does not pay staff in a org or mission, only a staff member who sold a book gets the book commission.

The org or mission pay was based upon services delivered, that would be courses and auditing services, and not book sales. This is part of the reason while on staff I decided to write many letters out, there was much idle time from lack of new people coming in you might say, so why not write letters out with a promo piece to get a few extra bucks. But all the thousands of letters I wrote did not really make me any money. But it was all part of the stat system.
 
.



.


I was personally never in Scientology. Whatever I know about Scientology I gleaned during a 34 year stretch when Mr. Hubbard and the COS was a customer of mine that I used to sell clipboards, graph paper, clay, mimeograph ink and foolscap goldenrod paper to.

After Mr. Hubbard passed away the new management stopped ordering through me and sadly I had to close my business. That's why I became very "antagonistic" and joined this website to vent my bye-past-charges.

In case anyone finds this interesting, here is where I first met Mr. Hubbard when i was a door-to-door office supplies salesman back in 1952. I knocked on his door at 5501 N 44th St, Phoenix, AZ 85018—and the rest is history!

l-ron-hubbard-on-porch-of-house-in-phoenix.jpg

(1952): photo taken moments after Mr. Hubbard placed his first order for graph paper and clipboards


...
​

.
"I was personally never in Scientology."

thanks, that's about what I came to.
 
Well this was back in the late 70s.
Most of the letters were written with more due consideration, from what I read within the files.

Maybe most of them were, definitely not all of them.

again, from what i hear it's not quite zero. but if they tracked the stat, they'd have seen it decline over the decades and could make a more informed decision about where to put their resources. oh, and they could even go back and analyze the . i think it's just another fairly obvious example of something that was outdated and poorly implemented, even when it was new to scn and touted by Hubbard as the best thing in this sector of the galaxy.



back then orgs didn't have vast files of people who'd lost interest decades ago. it was probably worth given the fewer and more recent files due consideration, and produced some real results.

Not sure what you're hearing exactly, I can assure you letters out is producing zero income (or near enough to be zero). Using CF might occasionally produce some income, but not letters out.
 
Looking for stories about how former staff/SO coped with the stat system.
as a side note from stats, don't ever tell a Sea Org member one never took drugs. OMG, when I said never took drugs to a Sea Org member, I was a hot target to join the Sea Org. That was very hard thing to navigate during my involvement. I even joined the Sea Org and blew from it, Long story.
 
..

HelluvaHoax said: "I was personally never in Scientology."

thanks, that's about what I came to.

.
Not sure I understood that.

Are you saying that even before I confessed that "I was personally never in Scientology" you had already obnosed that I was never in?

.
 
@Riddick
I am going to jump in here and clarify who my friend Helluva Hoax really is.

HH has been involved in every nook and cranny of SCN.

He was public. He was a sometime Mission Holder. He was staff. He was Sea Org. He was trained on NOTS and
was trained as an auditor and a CS, we went up to OT VII.

He knows whereof he speaks.
It would be foolish for anyone to underestimate just how *EDUCATED* HH is on the cult of SCN
 
Last edited:
what you missing to try to understand is that the book income is separate from Gross income. It's two systems. Book income does not pay staff in a org or mission, only a staff member who sold a book gets the book commission.

my point is not about exactly how scn orgs work, but that that they fail to manage things in ways that would have been best practices in businesses and other organizations by the '50s or '60s, like tracking just how much business (and profit) an activity such as letters out produced (and, how much labor was expended).

Not sure what you're hearing exactly, I can assure you letters out is producing zero income (or near enough to be zero). Using CF might occasionally produce some income, but not letters out.

i'm guessing 'using CF' in that context would mean phone calls, in contrast to letters out which as i understand it also uses CF. i have probably been lumping the two together.

yes, i'm pretty sure any of it doesn't produce much these days. but i've run across at least one case for example where they got someone back on lines and buying tens of thousands of dollars worth of services; that was more likely the result of a call than a letter, but I can't remember for certain. and Riddick has said that in his day letters out did occasionally produce a bit more business; and it's likely that back in the era of the '50s and '60s they were even somewhat more productive.

my point here is that i think we can see why the organization has hung onto something, in a pattern typical for scn: it originally was somewhat effective, and even still appears to produce occasional results, so it just ends up getting continued.

and in the end it's not really a proper, comprehensive system of management by statistics, even by the professional standards of the era.
 
Back
Top