Hubbard became an "implanter" in September 1963.

I'm sorry, I don't fall for the hypnosis crowd or theory. I've researched much on hypnosis including Braid and others.

James Braid | History of Hypnosis

You have to remember or recall or when I snap my fingers that Hubbard said 50% of the gains of going up the bridge to total freedom was by doing training, only a trained auditor will make it, that's rhetoric. And by doing training, guess what, you were listening and reading and word clearing and trying to get reads on the emeter by hubbard's rhetoric.

That was a logical appeal, but it's all false rhetoric including ethos, pathos and logos.
@Riddick, I'm not going to keep arguing with you about this. I think that would be a waste of time. Like I said (somewhere?) I'm not on a crusade here.

There was a time when I didn't buy the hypnosis thing either. That was because:

1. Hubbard said it wasn't hypnosis and I may still have been a little bit brainwashed;

2. I didn't know anything about hypnosis and I thought that

3. Being hypnotized meant you had to be in a real "yes, master" zombie-like trance.

As I learned more I gradually changed my opinion. Maybe you'll come around to accepting the hypnosis thing eventually. And if not, it's not the end of the world.
 
So do dreams. In DMSMH Hubbard says, "Dreams are crazy-house mirrors by which the analyzer looks down into the reactive bank" (paraphrase). That may be the ONLY official statement about the source of dreams in all scn literature. It's the only one I ever recall seeing.

I remember that because when I first read the book, I thought, "What? That's it? That's all he's going to say about it?" I knew dreams were considered very important by some other mental researchers; Freud, for example. I couldn't believe scn dismissed them so easily.

But wait: if dreams "look down into the reactive bank," then clears, who have supposedly erased their reactive minds, shouldn't dream, should they?

Oh damn it, I forgot about the BT's, and their reactive minds. That explains it. :duh: But there were no BT's in 1950. How did they explain it then? Of course that was probably the least of the things they couldn't explain. Like the lack of eidetic memory or computer-like calculating ability ... or clears catching colds ....
Dreams and dreaming is a big subject with lots of different opinions. Something I think I got from scn was if I awake from an unpleasant dream with the usual lingering memories I say or think "Cancelled!" and that's the end of it. Works for me.

Here's a take on dreams from Frank R. Wallace who authored a philosophy called "The Neo-Tech Discovery" around 1970.

Dreaming - Thinking in Reverse

Dreaming is the thinking process in reverse: Dreaming is the mind's garbage-disposing process. Dreams help purge the mind of unintegrated clutter, mysticism, and meaningless non sequiturs absorbed while awake. Thus contrary to the mystical notions of Freud, dreams have no meanings or connections to reality. And dream "analysis" is nothing more than feeding regurgitated clutter back into the mind. Plus, the more mysticism and non sequiturs that crowd the mind, the more frequent and nightmarish dreams become. Then subsequent dreams increasingly lose their therapeutic, garbage-disposal effects. If the mind then becomes increasingly loaded with mystical notions, one's dreams grow less effective in purging and protecting the mind from clutter. The mind then becomes unable to store, integrate, or function efficiently enough to let that person live as a happy, intelligent, productive, conscious being.
..........................................................................................................

Similar to Hubbard, Wallace had something to say about damn near everything and trashed other philosophies which didn't align with his including Scientology. Neo-Tech still survives as a small group called The Nouveau Tech Society. They send out a letter telling you you have been chosen to join a secret society where the secrets to Prosperity, Happiness and Romantic Love will be revealed. Even so, Wallace had some interesting and original ideas.

In the 1980's I got one of their letters. As an ex I was well aware of the come on but curiosity got the best of me and I bought their pricey "Neo-Tech Discovery" Manuscript as they called it. It was fun and interesting reading and kept me busy for awhile.
 
Last edited:
I'm sorry, I don't fall for the hypnosis crowd or theory. I've researched much on hypnosis including Braid and others.

James Braid | History of Hypnosis


You've mentioned a so-called "hypnosis theory" on multiple occasions but I've not seen anyone put forth any such theory. What exactly are you referring to? :unsure:

With regards to James Braid who you referenced, much has become known about hypnosis since his work 180 years ago! But I would bet good money that if Braid were with us today he would explain to you why the type of focused attention used in TR 0 could put someone into a trance state.
 
I'm sorry, I don't fall for the hypnosis crowd or theory. I've researched much on hypnosis including Braid and others.

I'm just curious, have you found even a single academic that agrees with you that "it is all rhetoric"? Any researchers within the field of psychology, sociology, or other relevant subjects who support your position? I've not heard of anyone making such a claim other than yourself.

Have you studied any of the cult experts who give their take on how cults recruit and maintain control of their members? I mentioned one of them earlier in this or another thread, Steven Hassan. His BITE model describes such methods and it is based on research of Robert Jay Lifton, Margaret Singer, Edgar Schein, Louis Jolyon West, and others who have researched mind control methods.

You seem to get frustrated and angry when others don't agree with your position that "it's all rhetoric", but given that others have seriously studied this issue including those I mentioned above it is you who have the burden of proof to show that they are wrong and you are correct. And up until this point you've failed to do that.
 
.


I'm just curious, have you found even a single academic that agrees with you that "it is all rhetoric"? Any researchers within the field of psychology, sociology, or other relevant subjects who support your position? I've not heard of anyone making such a claim other than yourself.

Have you studied any of the cult experts who give their take on how cults recruit and maintain control of their members? I mentioned one of them earlier in this or another thread, Steven Hassan. His BITE model describes such methods and it is based on research of Robert Jay Lifton, Margaret Singer, Edgar Schein, Louis Jolyon West, and others who have researched mind control methods.

You seem to get frustrated and angry when others don't agree with your position that "it's all rhetoric", but given that others have seriously studied this issue including those I mentioned above it is you who have the burden of proof to show that they are wrong and you are correct. And up until this point you've failed to do that.

.
I think it's fair to say that there is an obviously flawed syllogism at work there.

SYLLOGISTIC REASONING: "All mammals are animals. All elephants are mammals. Therefore, all elephants are animals."​
​
SYLLOGISTIC FALLACY: "All mind control involves persuasion. Rhetoric is a form of persuasion. Therefore all persuasion is rhetoric."​
​
SYLLOGISTIC FANTASY: "All rhetoric is a form of persuasion. All rhetoric that exists is rhetoric. Therefore everything that exists is rhetoric." LOL​
​
​
.
 
SYLLOGISTIC FALLACY

see also:


21-Fallacy-Watch-What-Is-Faulty-Generalisation-%E2%80%93-US.jpg
 
. . . they will respond with some bullshit rhetoric using a photoshop picture.

OK, then. You ask, I deliver. :coolwink:

rid-33.jpg​

Here are some of his earliest comments for those of you who
may need to straightwire back to basic-basic to find some relief. :whistle:

"hey ain't that the motto of the Sea Org, We Come Back? total rhetoric, or the art of persuasion."​
​
"that document wouldn't have been written by Hubbard, it's not the same rhetoric or writing style."​
​
"But anyways, that first paragraph is not Hubbard style of rhetoric or writing."​
​
"Norman Starkey is a rhetoric writer, just like Hubbard."​
 
You've mentioned a so-called "hypnosis theory" on multiple occasions but I've not seen anyone put forth any such theory. What exactly are you referring to? :unsure:

With regards to James Braid who you referenced, much has become known about hypnosis since his work 180 years ago! But I would bet good money that if Braid were with us today he would explain to you why the type of focused attention used in TR 0 could put someone into a trance state.
you have to ask yourself, how many people did TR0, and how come they are not still involved.
 
OK, then. You ask, I deliver. :coolwink:


Here are some of his earliest comments for those of you who
may need to straightwire back to basic-basic to find some relief. :whistle:

"hey ain't that the motto of the Sea Org, We Come Back? total rhetoric, or the art of persuasion."​
​
"that document wouldn't have been written by Hubbard, it's not the same rhetoric or writing style."​
​
"But anyways, that first paragraph is not Hubbard style of rhetoric or writing."​
​
"Norman Starkey is a rhetoric writer, just like Hubbard."​
yep, I said those things, still stand by what I said. You understand rhetoric means more than just the word persuasion, but maybe you don't.

I also posted this tread:

The Rhetoric and Master Plan of Dianetics and Scientology | Ex Scientologist Message Board Redux (exscn2.net)
 
Last edited:
you have to ask yourself, how many people did TR0, and how come they are not still involved.


Why would I ask myself that question when some of them ARE still involved, some of them 40 or more years later?

Why are they still in? Rhetoric?
 
Why would I ask myself that question when some of them ARE still involved, some of them 40 or more years later?

Why are they still in? Rhetoric?
you didn't ask yourself the question if TR0 was hypnosis, such as how many hours one did TR0? Who got all that TR0 and come they are not still involved. I myself got did lot's of TR0, maybe a few hundred hours, how come I left if TR0 was hypnosis? How come I,m sure many others who got lots of TR0 left if it was hypnosis?
 
you didn't ask yourself the question if TR0 was hypnosis, such as how many hours one did TR0? Who got all that TR0 and come they are not still involved. I myself got did lot's of TR0, maybe a few hundred hours, how come I left if TR0 was hypnosis? How come I,m sure many others who got lots of TR0 left if it was hypnosis?

You seem to be of the opinion that had TR 0 put people into a trance they never would have left. And that because most people DID leave that that proves TR 0 never did put people into a trance.

You are wrong on both counts.

And if you really researched hypnosis as you claimed to have done you wouldn't be questioning the ability of TR 0 to put people into a trance.
 
yep, I said those things, still stand by what I said.
I thought at least I'd get a compliment for the pretty Photoshop graphic I did. The character looks, shall I say, a bit dramatic. :coolwink:

I'm not the most intellectual person on the board. I don't "grok" all that logos-pathos-ethos stuff, I guess. Doesn't resonate. :innocent:
 
It is many years since I was involved in scientology but all of this talk about TR 0 putting people in a trance makes no sense to me. I can still remember the idea behind it - to "be there comfortably and confront". The whole point was to sit opposite someone and be "in present time" and confront the person. Being in a trance was exactly the opposite of the purpose of the drill.
 
It is many years since I was involved in scientology but all of this talk about TR 0 putting people in a trance makes no sense to me. I can still remember the idea behind it - to "be there comfortably and confront". The whole point was to sit opposite someone and be "in present time" and confront the person. Being in a trance was exactly the opposite of the purpose of the drill.


While being in a trance goes against the stated purpose of the drill it's not typical for all students to immediately achieve that purpose.

When I did my Pro-TRs at Flag it was typical for many students to be on that course for months.

When one's attention is narrowly focused on the person in front of you for hours it is easy to go into a light trance. I know there were long periods where I did yet the course supervisor usually had no clue.
 
While being in a trance goes against the stated purpose of the drill it's not typical for all students to immediately achieve that purpose.

When I did my Pro-TRs at Flag it was typical for many students to be on that course for months.

When one's attention is narrowly focused on the person in front of you for hours it is easy to go into a light trance. I know there were long periods where I did yet the course supervisor usually had no clue.

Has Riddick provided a definition for the word hypnosis?

Also, the word "hypnotic" - an adjective - can be useful.

Something can be hypnotic, or have an hypnotic aspect, without enslaving a person for the rest of his life. It might even be beneficial in some instances.

(I remember a man and wife who did the Pro TRs course after it just came out. He had just received his Masters Degree from the School of Visual Arts in New York City. Although he was older than I, we had some mutual friends. They'd sometimes visit me while I was working at my summer job at the seashore to pay for the Scientology Academy levels.)

They were originally on the ordinary TRs course, and then they were placed on the PRO TRs when it was released.

It took several months and cost $35.

The husband thought it would be an interesting experience, and might also help his wife, which it did.

At the end of the course, realizing that this course was obviously the best cost/benefit ratio in Scientology, and seeing the ubiquitous photos of Hubbard in the Org, he decided to creatively and mischievously end his and his wife's association with Scientology.

In his Success Story he wrote that "Now that I've completed the pro TRs course, I'm going to become a leader in the Hare Krishna movement."

The (e-meter operating) Examiner shouted, "You're insane!"

He exited the Scientology Org, and had a good laugh.


118_1976_11-11-3.jpg

New York Central Park, circa 1970

​
 
The (e-meter operating) Examiner shouted, "You're insane!"

that can't be true, we know auditors always follow the Code and would never invalidate a PC.... :blink:

(it appears to me that the way Hubbard set up auditing, PCs are actually often told, or lead or suggested, what to think, even though it's rather subtle or even covert.)
 
Has Riddick provided a definition for the word hypnosis?

Also, the word "hypnotic" - an adjective - can be useful.

Something can be hypnotic, or have an hypnotic aspect, without enslaving a person for the rest of his life. It might even be beneficial in some instances.
<snip>

On a couple of occasions he's made comments like this:

I'm sorry, I don't fall for the hypnosis crowd or theory.

I asked him to clarify what he means by that but he just ignores such questions.

From his line of questioning though he seems to believe that because most people left Scientology that that proves no hypnosis ever took place.

I agree that hypnosis can be beneficial in some situations, and suspect that that may have been the case during Book I auditing.

But given Hubbard's attitude towards other people and his expertise with hypnosis I would bet that he considered how to use it against us if he possibly could. He wrote (in his "admissions"):

"Material things are yours for the asking. Men are your slaves."

"Your writing has a deep hypnotic effect on people and they are always pleased with what you write. "

He doesn't exactly sound like Mankind's Greatest Friend when he writes those types of things. :D
 
This is an excerpt from an affidavit of Monica Pignotti:


After attending the free lecture at the Scientology mission in Salt Lake City, I purchased the book, Dianetics, the Modern Science of Mental Health, the 1950 bestseller by L. Ron Hubbard. I was very impressed and fascinated with the book and decided to sign up for the first course, which was called the Communications course. I started this course in January 1971, which I attended two evenings a week. The course consisted mainly of drills called Training Regimens ("TRs"). The first TR was called TR-O, where I was required to sit face to face with a partner (another student), maintaining eye contact and "just be there", which meant to sit there without any movement or thought whatsoever. The drill is passed when the person can do this for two hours.

I was unaware at the time that every time I did TR-O, I was going into a hypnotic trance state. I only realized this years later, after leaving the group, when I read about hypnosis and experienced a trance state from a legitimate psychologist who did hypnosis on me. The state I was in then was identical to the state I was in when I did TR-O.

TRs are done regularly and often by Scientologists on all levels. Pretty soon, for me, just walking into the courseroom induced a trance state in me. Hubbard claimed to be vehemently against hypnosis, but, nevertheless, this is what I experienced. Being in this trance state made me extremely vulnerable to the material I was reading, which basically stated that Scientology is the only road to total freedom, that we were in a labyrinth as citizens of the planet earth and the only way out of this "trap" was through Scientology. A very dreary picture was being painted of the world outside of Scientology, which was referred to as the wog world.
 
:scratch:
How did this become a Riddick "If fudgsicles taste so good how come you're eating that hamburger" thread?

Oh never mind.


that can't be true, we know auditors always follow the Code and would never invalidate a PC.... :blink:

There may have been extenuating circumstances. The Hare Krishna people - with their endless chanting, shaved heads, and soffron robes - were a constant source of annoyance, for Scientologists, in downtown Manhattan where the Org was located.

And that would have been compounded with a well known former staff member and staff auditor - famous for his encyclopedic knowledge of Scientology tech - having just become a guru and published his own successful book.
1628790093


The book even included a chapter on Scientology, describing it as a political not a spiritual organization.
Sometime later I saw Franklin Jones' file in the Guardians Office file cabinet for "squirrel" groups. It was extensive. It was "personal" for the New York Scientology staff. He had been one of them - knew them from the inside - and then defected and started his own cult. It kind of blew their minds. It bugged them terribly.

And now here's this guy telling them that, as a result of the wins he had on the Communications Course (which normally would have taken a couple of days but, as the Hard TRs course, took months, and still only cost $35) he was going to become a leader in the Hare Krishna movement. It was too much. The person just popped a cork, as the saying goes.

(it appears to me that the way Hubbard set up auditing, PCs are actually often told, or lead or suggested, what to think, even though it's rather subtle or even covert.)

Yep. Scientology is loaded with suggestion and evaluation. And at the "upper levels" it's not subtle.
 
Back
Top